Enter the name for this tabbed section: What is Central Bargaining?
What is Central Bargaining?
The Ontario Hospital Association (OHA) is funded by the Ontario Ministry of Health to bargain provincially with the major unions in the hospital sector: the Ontario Nurses Association, the Canadian Union of Public Employees, the Service Employees International Union and the Ontario Public Sector Employees Union.

Bargaining unit of each union and their respective employers can choose to bargain provincially at a single table. For CUPE, approximately 25,000 employees at 65 hospitals across the province are included in negotiations of three master collective agreements: one for combined full and part time units, one for full time employees only and one for part time only units.

There are only four CUPE organized work places which do not participate in central bargaining with the Ontario Hospital Association and three of these units follow the central settlement.
Hospital employers and local union representatives elect central bargaining teams, which conduct the negotiations. CUPE units have the Ontario Council of Hospital Unions as the bargaining agent in negotiations.

The first step in negotiations is to agree on a Memorandum of Conditions for Joint Bargaining. This Memorandum outlines the timetable for central and local negotiations, identifies the issues that are to be bargained provincially and locally, distinguishes the units and employers who are participating and indicates how unresolved issues will be dealt with.

Following the development of this Memorandum of Conditions, bargaining proposals are then exchanged face-to-face. Unresolved issues are usually referred to arbitration, by an independent third party.
Enter the name for this tabbed section: OCHU Bargaining Process
OCHU Bargaining Proposals Process
The following is the process that OCHU follows when developing bargaining proposals once negotiations over the central collective agreement begins.

1. Consultation with local leaders
2. Distribution of bargaining surveys to OCHU members
3. Provincial teleconference call with all OCHU affiliated locals to adopt priorities for membership balloting
4. Membership balloting
5. Proposal development

Executive Recommendation of a timetable to prepare for the 2006 central negotiations

Whereas extensive preparation and consultation is needed in order to identify priorities for the next round of bargaining;

And whereas it is our goal to negotiate a collective agreement prior to the expiry of our contract;

Therefore be it resolved that this convention authorize the Central Bargaining Committee to prepare for negotiations following the timetable outlined below:

1. Initial consultations with local leaders on bargaining priorities would take place in area meetings in the fall of 2005.
2. All locals will be asked to mail the bargaining survey to their members in January 2006.
3. Initial discussions with the OHA about a Memorandum of Conditions for Joint Bargaining will take place in the fall of 2003.
4. A second series of area meeting with local leaders would be held in the fall of 2003 to discuss priorities in depth and to review the notes from the first series of area meetings.
5. The bargaining survey would be analyzed by the Research Department February to March 2006.
6. In January 2006 area meetings to review the membership bargaining survey results and the notes from the 2nd series of area meetings would be held. These meetings will also review draft bargaining priority recommendations.
7. A bargaining conference will be held in April 2006 to formally receive the results of the membership bargaining survey and the regional consultations. This conference will vote on the priorities that will go forward for membership balloting.
8. In April 2006 a Bargaining Conference vote on priorities would take place.
9. The Central Bargaining Committee will draft proposals based on the results of that voting, together with any priorities voted on at the bargaining conference. That package will be mailed out to all locals.
10. A Memorandum of Conditions for Joint Bargaining would be negotiated with the OHA spring of 2006.
11. Proposals would be exchanged with the OHA in July 2004.
12. A provincial teleconference call will be held once we have received the employer’s central proposals.
13. Direct negotiations on central issues will begin in August 2004.

Adopted by OCHU general membership at the OCHU Annual Convention (April 2003).
Enter the name for this tabbed section: Collective Agreements

COMBINED FULL TIME/PART TIME COLLECTIVE AGREEMENT

between (hereinafter called the "Hospital") and CUPE LOCAL
Expires: September 28, 2013

Download Full version

ARTICLE 1 PREAMBLE

1.01 PREAMBLE

The general purpose of this Agreement is to establish and maintain collective bargaining relations between the Hospital and the employees covered by this Agreement; to provide for ongoing means of communication between the Union and the Hospital and the prompt disposition of grievances and the final settlement of disputes and to establish and maintain mutually satisfactory wages, hours of work and other conditions of employment in accordance with the provisions of this Agreement.

It is recognized that the employees wish to work efficiently together with the Hospital to secure the best possible care and health protection for patients.

1.02 FEMININE/MASCULINE PRONOUNS

Wherever the feminine pronoun is used in this Agreement, it includes the masculine pronoun and vice versa where the context so requires.

ARTICLE 2 DEFINITIONS

2.01 TEMPORARY EMPLOYEE

Employees may be hired for a specific term not to exceed six (6) months, to replace an employee who will be on approved leave of absence, absence due to WSIB disability, sick leave, long term disability or to perform a special non recurring task. This term may be extended a further six (6) months on mutual agreement of the Union, employee and Hospital or by the Hospital on its own up to twelve (12) months where the leave of the person being replaced extends that far. The period of employment of such persons will not exceed the absentee's leave. The release or discharge of such persons shall not be the subject of a grievance or arbitration.

This clause would not preclude such employees from using the job posting provision under the collective agreement and any successful applicant who has completed his probation period will be credited with the appropriate seniority.

The Hospital will outline to employees selected to fill such temporary vacancies and the Union, the circumstances giving rise to the vacancy, and the special conditions relating to such employment.


2.02 PART TIME COMMITMENT

The Hospital shall not refuse to accept an offer from an employee to make a written commitment to be available for work on a regular predetermined basis solely for the purpose of utilizing casual employees so as to restrict the numbers of regular part time employees.

2.03; 2.04 REGULAR PART TIME EMPLOYEE; CASUAL EMPLOYEE

Any definition of a regular part-time employee or of a casual employee that existed in the hospital's expiring collective agreement will be continued as the concluding sub-section(s) of this Article.

ARTICLE 3 RELATIONSHIP

3.01 NO DISCRIMINATION

The parties agree that there shall be no discrimination within the meaning of the Ontario Human Rights Code against any employee by the Union or the Hospital by reason of race, creed, colour, age, sex, marital status, nationality, ancestry or place of origin, family status, handicap, sexual orientation, political affiliation or activity, or place of residence. The Hospital and the Union further agree that there will be no intimidation, discrimination, interference, restraint or coercion exercised or practised by either of them or their representatives or members, because of an employee's membership or non-membership in a Union or because of his activity or lack of activity in the Union.

The Union shall be provided a copy of any written notice provided to an employee that he or she may be subject to termination, demotion, transfer, or other adverse impact for innocent absenteeism.

ARTICLE 4 STRIKES & LOCKOUTS

The Union agrees there shall be no strikes and the Hospital agrees there shall be no lockouts so long as this Agreement continues to operate. The terms "strike" and "lockout" shall bear the meaning given them in the Ontario Labour Relations Act.

ARTICLE 5 UNION SECURITY

5.01 T4 SLIPS

The Hospital will provide each employee with a T 4 supplementary slip showing

the dues deducted in the previous year for income tax purposes where such information is available or becomes readily available through the Hospital's payroll system.

5.02 NOTIFICATION TO UNION

The Hospital will provide the union with a list, monthly, of all hirings, lay offs, recalls, and positions which have been vacated within the bargaining unit where such information is available or becomes readily available through the Hospital's payroll system.

5.03 EMPLOYEE INTERVIEW

A new employee will have the opportunity to meet with a representative of the Union in the employ of the Hospital for a period of up to 15 minutes during the employee's orientation period without loss of regular earnings. The purpose of the meeting will be to acquaint the employee with such representative of the Union and the collective agreement.

Such meetings may be arranged collectively or individually for employees by the Hospital as part of the orientation program.

5.04 NO OTHER AGREEMENTS

No employee shall be required or permitted to make any written or verbal agreement with the Hospital or its representative(s) which conflicts with the terms of this agreement.

No individual employee or group of employees shall undertake to represent the union at meetings with the Hospital without proper authorization from the union.

ARTICLE 6 UNION REPRESENTATION AND COMMITTEES

6.01 UNION ACTIVITY ON PREMISES AND/OR ACCESS TO PREMISES

The Union agrees that neither it, nor its officers, agents, representatives and members will engage in the solicitation of members, holding of meetings or any other Union activities on Hospital premises or on Hospital time without the prior approval of the Hospital, except as specifically provided for in this Agreement. Such approval will not be unreasonably denied.


6.02 LABOUR-MANAGEMENT COMMITTEE

(a) Where the parties mutually agree that there are matters of mutual concern and interest that would be beneficial if discussed at a Labour Management Committee Meeting during the term of this Agreement, the following shall apply.

(b) An equal number of representatives of each party as mutually agreed shall meet at a time and place mutually satisfactory. A request for a meeting hereunder will be made in writing prior to the date proposed and accompanied by an agenda of matters proposed to be discussed, which shall not include matters that are properly the subject of grievance or negotiations for the amendment or renewal of this agreement.

Any representative(s) attending such meetings during their regularly scheduled hours of work shall not lose regular earnings as a result of such attendance.

(c) It is agreed that the topic of a rehabilitation program for drug and alcohol abuse is an appropriate topic for the Labour-Management Committee.

It is also agreed that the topic of the utilization of full-time and part-time staff is an appropriate topic for the Labour-Management Committee. The committee shall have access to work schedules and job postings upon request.

(d) It is understood that joint meetings with other Labour Management Committees in the Hospital may be scheduled concerning issues of mutual interest if satisfactory to all concerned.

(e) Where two or more agreements exist between a Hospital and CUPE the Committee may be a joint one representing employees under both agreements, unless otherwise agreed.

6.03 LOCAL BARGAINING COMMITTEE

The Hospital agrees to recognize a negotiating committee comprised of hospital employee representatives of the Union for the purpose of negotiating a renewal agreement (as set out in the Local Provisions Appendix). The Hospital agrees to pay members of the negotiating committee for straight time wages lost from their regularly scheduled working hours spent in direct negotiations for a renewal agreement, up to but not including arbitration. Nothing in this provision is intended to preclude the Union negotiating committee from having the assistance of any representatives of the Canadian Union of Public Employees when negotiating with the Hospital.

When direct negotiations begin or end within ten (10) hours of a negotiating team member's scheduled shift, the Hospital will endeavour to provide a one day's leave of absence without pay, to provide a sufficient rest break if the employee so requests. Such request shall not be unreasonably denied. Such leave shall be considered leave of absence for union business, but shall not be deducted from the Union entitlement under Article 12.02.

6.04 - CENTRAL BARGAINING COMMITTEE

(a) In central bargaining between the Canadian Union of Public Employees and the participating hospitals, an employee serving on the Union's Central Negotiating Committee shall be paid for time lost from his normal straight time working hours at his regular rate of pay and without loss of leave credits for attending central negotiating meetings with the Hospitals' Central Negotiating Committee in direct negotiations up to the point of arbitration. In addition, an employee serving on the Union’s Central Negotiating Committee shall be paid for time lost from his normal straight time working hours at his regular rate of pay and without loss of leave credits for two (2) days of preparation time for such central negotiating meetings with the Hospital’s Central negotiating Committee. Upon reference to arbitration, the Negotiating Committee members shall receive unpaid time off for the purpose of attending arbitration hearings.

It is understood and agreed that the maximum number of Union Central Negotiating Committee members entitled to payment under this provision shall be eight (8), and in no case will more than one employee from a hospital be entitled to such payment.

The Union shall advise the Hospitals' Central Negotiating Committee, before negotiations commence, of those employees to be paid under this provision. The

Hospitals' Central Negotiating Committee shall advise the eight (8) Hospitals accordingly.

(b) Vice-Presidents of the Ontario Council of Hospital Unions shall be granted leave of absence by their employers in accordance with (a) above or Article 12.02 as the case may be, in order to fulfil the duties of their position.

6.05 UNION STEWARDS

(a) The Hospital agrees to recognize Union stewards to be elected or appointed from amongst employees in the bargaining unit who have completed their probationary period for the purpose of dealing with Union business as provided under this Collective Agreement.

(b) A Chief Steward or designate may, in the absence of any steward, assist in the presentation of any grievance, or with any steward function.

(c) The Union shall keep the Hospital notified in writing of the names of Union stewards appointed or selected under this Article as well as the effective date of their respective appointments.

(d) It is agreed that Union stewards have their regular duties and responsibilities to perform for the Hospital and shall not leave their regular duties without first obtaining permission from their immediate supervisor. If, in the performance of his duties, a Union steward is required to enter an area within the Hospital in which he is not originally employed, he shall report his presence to the supervisor in the area immediately upon entering it. Such permission shall not be unreasonably withheld. When resuming his regular duties and responsibilities, such steward shall again report to his immediate supervisor. A Union steward shall suffer no loss of earnings for time spent in performing the above duties during his regular scheduled working hours.

(e) Nothing in this Article shall preclude full-time stewards from representing part-time employees and vice-versa.

(f) The number of stewards and the areas which they represent, are to be determined locally.

6.06 - GRIEVANCE COMMITTEE

The Hospital will recognize a Grievance Committee composed of the Chief Steward and not more than (as set out in Local Provisions Appendix) employees selected by the Union who have completed their probationary period. A general representative of the Union may be present at any meeting of the Committee. The purpose of the Committee is to deal with complaints or grievances as set out in this Collective Agreement.

The Union shall keep the Hospital notified in writing of the names of the members of the Grievance Committee appointed or selected under this Article as well as the effective date of their respective appointments.

A Committee member shall suffer no loss of earnings for time spent during their regular scheduled working hours in attending grievance meetings with the Hospital up to, but not including arbitration. The number of employees on the Grievance Committee shall be determined locally.

ARTICLE 7 GRIEVANCE AND ARBITRATION PROCEDURE

7.01 For purposes of this Agreement, a grievance is defined as a difference arising between the parties relating to the interpretation, application, administration or alleged violation of the Agreement including any question as to whether a matter is arbitrable.

7.02 At the time formal discipline is imposed or at any stage of the grievance procedure an employee shall have the right upon request to the presence of his/her steward. In the case of suspension or discharge the Hospital shall notify the employee of this right in advance.

7.03 It is the mutual desire of the parties hereto that complaints of employees shall be adjusted as quickly as possible, and it is understood that an employee has no grievance until he has first given his immediate supervisor the opportunity of adjusting his complaint. The grievor may have the assistance of a union steward if he or she so desires. Such complaint shall be discussed with his immediate supervisor within nine (9) calendar days after the circumstances giving rise to it have occurred or ought reasonably to have come to the attention of the employee and failing settlement within nine (9) calendar days, it shall then be taken up as a grievance within nine (9) calendar days following advice of his immediate supervisor's decision in the following manner and sequence:

Step No. 1

The employee, who may be accompanied by a steward, may submit a written grievance signed by the employee to (designated by Hospital). The grievance shall identify the nature of the grievance and the remedy sought and should identify the provisions of the Agreement which are alleged to be violated. The Union and the Hospital may, if they so desire, meet to discuss the grievance at a time and place suitable to both parties. The (designate) will deliver his decision in writing within nine (9) calendar days following the day on which the grievance was presented to him. Failing settlement or response, then:

Step No. 2

Within nine (9) calendar days following the decision in Step No.1, the grievance may be submitted in writing to the (designated by Hospital). A meeting will then be held between the (designate) and the Grievance Committee within nine (9) calendar days of the submission of the grievance at Step No. 2 unless extended by agreement of the parties. It is understood and agreed that a representative of the Canadian Union of Public Employees and the grievor may be present at the meeting. It is further understood that the (designate) may have such counsel and assistance as he may desire at such meeting. The decision of the Hospital shall be delivered in writing within nine (9) calendar days following the date of such meeting.

7.04 A complaint or grievance arising directly between the Hospital and the Union concerning the interpretation, application or alleged violation of the Agreement shall be originated at Step No. 2 within fourteen (14) calendar days following the circumstances giving rise to the complaint or grievance. It is expressly understood, however, that the provisions of this Article may not be used with respect to a grievance directly affecting an employee which such employee could himself institute and the regular grievance procedure shall not be thereby bypassed.

7.05 Where a number of employees have identical grievances and each employee would be entitled to grieve separately they may present a group grievance in writing identifying each employee who is grieving to the Department Head or his designee within fourteen (14) calendar days after the circumstances giving rise to the grievance have occurred or ought reasonably to have come to the attention of the employee(s). The grievance shall then be treated as being initiated at Step No. 2 and the applicable provisions of this Article shall then apply with respect to the processing of such grievance.

7.06 The release or discharge of an employee during the probationary period shall not be the subject of a grievance or arbitration. A claim by an employee who has completed his probationary period that he has been unjustly discharged or suspended shall be treated as a grievance if a written statement of such grievance is lodged by the employee with the Hospital at Step No. 2 within seven (7) calendar days after the date the discharge or suspension is effected. Such special grievance may be settled under the Grievance or Arbitration Procedure by:

(a) confirming the Hospital's action in dismissing the employee; or
(b) reinstating the employee with or without full compensation for the time lost; or
(c) by any other arrangement which may be deemed just and equitable.

Wherever the Hospital deems it necessary to suspend or discharge an employee, the Hospital shall notify the Union of such suspension or discharge in writing. The Hospital agrees that it will not suspend, discharge or otherwise discipline an employee who has completed his probationary period, without just cause.

7.07 (a) Failing settlement under the foregoing procedure of any grievance between the parties arising from the interpretation, application, administration or alleged violation of this Agreement, including any question as to whether a matter is arbitrable, such grievance may be submitted to arbitration as hereinafter provided. If no written request for arbitration is received within eighteen (18) calendar days after the decision under Step No. 2 is given, the grievance shall be deemed to have been abandoned. Where such a written request is postmarked within sixteen (16) calendar days after the decision under Step No. 2, it will be deemed to have been received within the time limits.

(b) The parties agree that it is their intent to resolve grievances without recourse to arbitration, wherever possible. Therefore, notwithstanding (a) above, the parties may, upon mutual agreement, engage the services of a mediator in an effort to resolve the grievance and may extend the time limits for the request for arbitration. The parties will share equally the fees and expenses, if any, of the mediator.

7.08 All agreements reached under the Grievance Procedure between the representatives of the Hospital and the representatives of the Union will be final and binding upon the Hospital and the Union and the employees.

7.09 When either party requests that any matter be submitted to arbitration as provided in the foregoing Article, it shall make such request in writing addressed to the other party to this Agreement, and at the same time name a nominee. Within seven (7) calendar days thereafter the other party shall name a nominee, provided, however, that if such party fails to name a nominee as herein required, the Minister of Labour for the Province of Ontario shall have power to effect such appointment upon application thereto by the party invoking Arbitration Procedure. The two nominees shall attempt to select by agreement a chairman of the Arbitration Board. If they are unable to agree upon such a chairman within a period of fourteen (14) calendar days, they shall then request the Minister of Labour for the Province of Ontario to appoint a chairman.

7.10 No person may be appointed as an arbitrator who has been involved in an attempt to negotiate or settle the grievance.

7.11 No matter may be submitted to arbitration which has not been properly carried through all requisite steps of the Grievance Procedure.

7.12 The Arbitration Board shall not be authorized to make any decision inconsistent with the provisions of this Agreement, nor to alter, modify, add to or amend any part of this Agreement.

7.13 The proceedings of the Arbitration Board will be expedited by the parties hereto and the decision of the majority and, where there is no majority the decision of the chairman will be final and binding upon the parties hereto and the employee or employees concerned.

7.14 Each of the parties hereto will bear the expense of the nominee appointed by it and the parties will share equally the fees and expenses, if any, of the chairman of the Arbitration Board.

7.15 The time limits set out in the Grievance and Arbitration Procedures herein are mandatory and failure to comply strictly with such time limits except by the written agreement of the parties, shall result in the grievance being deemed to have been abandoned subject only to the provisions of Section 48 (16) of The Labour Relations Act.

7.16 Wherever Arbitration Board is referred to in the Agreement, the parties may mutually agree in writing to substitute a single arbitrator for the Arbitration Board at the time of reference to arbitration and the other provisions referring to Arbitration Board shall appropriately apply.

ARTICLE 8 ACCESS TO FILES

8.01 ACCESS TO PERSONNEL FILE

Each employee shall have reasonable access to his/her personnel file for the purpose of reviewing any evaluations or formal disciplinary notations contained therein, in the presence of the Director of Personnel or designate. An employee has the right to request copies of any evaluations in this file.

8.02 CLEARING OF RECORD

Any letter of reprimand, suspension or any other sanction will be removed from the record of an employee eighteen (18) months following the receipt of such letter, suspension or other sanction provided that such employee’s record has been discipline free for one year. All leaves of absence in excess of ten (10) calendar days will not count toward either of the above periods.

ARTICLE 9 SENIORITY

9.01 PROBATIONARY PERIOD

A new employee will be considered on probation until he has completed forty-five (45) days of work (or 337.5 hours of work for employees whose regular hours of work are other than the standard work day), within any twelve (12) calendar months. Upon completion of the probationary period he shall be credited with seniority equal to forty-five (45) working days. With the written consent of the Hospital, the probationary employee and the President of the Local Union or designate, such probationary period may be extended. Any extensions agreed to will be in writing and will specify the length of the extension. The release or discharge of an employee during the probationary period shall not be the subject of a grievance or arbitration.

9.02 - DEFINITION OF SENIORITY

Full time employees will accumulate seniority on the basis of their continuous service in the bargaining unit from the last date of hire, except as otherwise provided herein.

Part-time employees, including casual employees, will accumulate seniority on the basis of one (1) year's seniority for each 1725 hours worked in the bargaining unit as of the last date of hire, except as otherwise provided herein.

Seniority will operate on a bargaining unit wide basis.

A part-time employee cannot accrue more than one year’s seniority in a twelve (12) month period. The twelve (12) month period shall be determined locally.*

9.03 LOSS OF SENIORITY

An employee shall lose all seniority and service and shall be deemed to have terminated if he:

(a) resigns;

(b) is discharged and not reinstated through the grievance/arbitration procedure;

(c) is retired;

(d) is absent from scheduled work for a period of three (3) or more consecutive working days without notifying the Hospital of such absence and providing to the Hospital a satisfactory reason;

(e) has been laid off for forty-eight (48) months;

(f) if the employee has been laid off and fails to return to work within seven (7) calendar days after that employee has been notified by the Hospital through registered mail addressed to the last address on the records of the Hospital, subject to any special provisions regarding temporary vacancies noted under the heading of Layoff and Recall.

9.04 EFFECT OF ABSENCE

((a), (b) and (c) of the following clause are applicable to full time employees only)

Unless otherwise provided in the Collective Agreement:

(a) It is understood that during an approved unpaid absence not exceeding thirty (30) continuous days or any approved absence paid by the Hospital, both seniority and service will accrue.

(b) During an unpaid absence exceeding thirty (30) continuous calendar days, credit for service for purposes of salary increment, vacation, sick leave, or
any other benefits under any provisions of the Collective Agreement or elsewhere, shall be suspended for the period of the absence in excess of thirty (30) continuous calendar days, the benefits concerned appropriately reduced on a pro rata basis and the employee's anniversary date adjusted accordingly. In addition, the employee will become responsible for full payment of any subsidized employee benefits in which he/she is participating for the period of absence, except that the Hospital will continue to pay its share of the premiums up to thirty (30) months while an employee is in receipt of WSIB benefits*. Such payment shall also continue while an employee is on sick leave (including the Employment Insurance Period) to a maximum of thirty (30) months from the time the absence commenced.

Notwithstanding this provision, service shall accrue for a period of fifteen (15) weeks if an employee's absence is due to a disability resulting in WSIB benefits.*

(c) It is further understood that during such unpaid absence, credit for seniority for purposes of promotion, demotion, transfer or lay-off shall be suspended and not accrue during the period of absence. Notwithstanding this provision seniority shall accrue for the duration of the absence, if an employee's absence is due to a disability resulting in WSIB benefits*, or while an employee is on paid or unpaid sick leave (including the Employment Insurance Period).

(d) Part-time employees shall accrue seniority for the duration of the absence, if an employee’s absence is due to a disability resulting in WSIB benefits.*

Part-time employees shall accrue service for a period of fifteen (15) weeks if absent due to a disability resulting in WSIB benefits, on the basis of what the employee’s normal regular hours of work would have been.

*Note: Add the words "or L.T.D. benefits" only in agreements providing L.T.D. benefits.

9.05 - JOB POSTING

Any provision pertaining to definition of temporary vacancies, non bargaining unit applications, outside advertising, interim placements or criteria for selection except as it relates to promotions and transfers that existed in the hospital's expiring collective agreement will be continued as the last paragraph of this Article.

(a) Where a permanent vacancy occurs in a classification within the bargaining unit or a new position within the bargaining unit is established by the Hospital, such vacancy shall be posted for a period of seven (7) consecutive calendar days. Applications for such vacancy shall be made in writing within the seven (7) day period referred to herein.

(b) The postings shall stipulate the qualifications, classifications, rate of pay, department and shift and a copy shall be provided to the Chief Steward.

(c) Vacancies created by the filling of an initial permanent vacancy will be posted for a period of three (3) consecutive calendar days, excluding Saturdays, Sundays and Holidays. Applications for such vacancies shall be made in writing within the three (3) day period referred to herein.

(d) In matters of promotion and staff transfer appointment shall be made of the senior applicant able to meet the normal requirements of the job. Successful employees need not be considered for other vacancies within a six (6) month period unless an opportunity arises which allows the employee to change his or her permanent status.

(e) The Hospital agrees that it shall post permanent vacant positions within 30 calendar days of the position becoming vacant, unless the Hospital provides the Union notice under Article 9.08(A)(a) of its intention to eliminate the position.

(f) The name of the successful applicant will be posted on the bulletin board for a period of seven (7) calendar days.

(g) Where there are no successful applicants from within this bargaining unit for vacant positions referred to in this Article, employees in other CUPE bargaining units at the Hospital will be selected in accordance with the criteria for selection above, prior to considering persons who are not members of CUPE bargaining units at the Hospital. The employees eligible for consideration shall be limited to those employees who have applied for the position in accordance with this Article, and selection shall be made in accordance with this Article.

(h) The successful applicant shall be allowed a trial period of up to thirty (30) days, during which the Hospital will determine if the employee can satisfactorily perform the job. Within this period the employee may voluntarily return, or be returned by the Hospital to the position formerly occupied, without loss of seniority. The vacancy resulting from the posting may be filled on a temporary basis until the trial period is completed.

(i) A list of vacancies filled in the preceding month under this Article and the names of the successful applicants will be posted, with a copy provided to the union.

9.06 - TRANSFER AND SENIORITY OUTSIDE THE BARGAINING UNIT

(a) It is understood that an employee shall not be transferred by the Hospital to a position outside the bargaining unit without his consent except in the case of temporary assignments not exceeding six (6) months. This period may be extended a further six (6) months upon the agreement of the employee and the Hospital. Such employees on temporary assignments shall remain members of the bargaining unit.

(b) An employee who is transferred to a position outside the bargaining unit shall not, subject to (c) below, accumulate seniority. In the event the employee is returned by the Hospital to a position in the bargaining unit within twenty-four (24) months of the transfer he or she shall be credited with the seniority held at the time of transfer and resume accumulation from the date of his or her return to the bargaining unit. An employee not returned to the bargaining unit within 24 months shall forfeit bargaining unit seniority.

(c) In the event an employee transferred out of the bargaining unit under (a) or (b) above is returned to the bargaining unit within a period of twelve (12) calendar months, he shall accumulate seniority during the period of time outside the bargaining unit.

9.07(A) - TRANSFER OF SENIORITY AND SERVICE

Effective (the date as set out in the Local Provisions Appendix) and for employees who transfer subsequent to (the effective date as set out in the Local Provisions Appendix):

For application of seniority for purposes of promotion, demotion, transfer, layoff and recall and service (including meeting any waiting period or other entitlement requirements) for purposes of vacation entitlement, HOODIP or equivalent, health and welfare benefit plans, and wage progression:

(i) an employee whose status is changed from full time to part-time shall receive full credit for his seniority and service;

(ii) an employee whose status is changed from part-time to full time shall receive credit for his seniority and service on the basis of one (1) year for each 1725 hours worked.

The above-noted employee shall be allowed a trial period of up to thirty (30) days, during which the Hospital will determine if the employee can satisfactorily perform the job. Within this period the employee may voluntarily return, or be returned without loss of seniority to his former duties on the same shift in the same department and at the appropriate rate of pay, subject to any changes which would have occurred had he not transferred.

9.07(B) – PORTABILITY OF SERVICE

An employee hired by the Hospital with recent and related experience may claim consideration for such experience at the time of hiring on a form to be supplied by the Hospital. Any such claim shall be accompanied by verification of previous related experience. The Hospital shall then evaluate such experience during the probationary period following hiring. Where in the opinion of the Hospital such experience is determined to be relevant, the employee shall be slotted in that step of the wage progression consistent with one (1) year's service for every one (1) year of related experience in the classification upon completion of the employee's probationary period. It is understood and agreed that the foregoing shall not constitute a violation of the wage schedule under the collective agreement.

9.07(C) – TRANSFORMATION IN HEALTH CARE

Seniority Recognition

Without prejudice to the Union’s or Hospitals’ rights under the collective agreement or the Labour Relations Act and/or the Public Sector Labour Relations Transition Act, the parties agree that non-unionized employees who are affected (via relocation/transfer*) shall, when entering the bargaining unit, be afforded seniority and service in accordance with the anniversary of their date of hire (or hours worked) from their original Hospital. Such anniversary date shall be calculated in accordance with the relevant provisions of the relevant collective agreement.

Right to Return or Transfer

Employees who are relocated/transferred* to another employer by the Hospital will retain their seniority and service at their original hospital for a 48-month period.

Without prejudice to the Union’s or Hospitals’ rights under the collective agreement or the Labour Relations Act and/or the Public Sector Labour Relations Transition Act, employees relocated/transferred* shall have the right to post for vacancies that arise, prior to or subsequent to the relocation/transfer*, at their originating Hospital for that 48-month period.

If they are the successful applicant, they will return to the employ of the Hospital with seniority accrued and service intact but not accrued, for the period that the employee was relocated/transferred* to another employer.

*Pursuant to a “Sale of Business” under Section 69 of the Labour Relations Act, or to a transfer pursuant to the Public Sector Labour Relations Transition Act.

9.08(A) NOTICE AND REDEPLOYMENT COMMITTEE

(a) Notice

In the event of a proposed layoff at the Hospital of a permanent or long-term nature or the elimination of a position within the bargaining unit, the Hospital shall:

(i) provide the Union with no less than five (5) months' written notice of the proposed layoff or elimination of position; and

(ii) provide to the affected employee(s), if any, who will be laid off with no less than five (5) months' written notice of layoff, or pay in lieu thereof.

Note: Where a proposed layoff results in the subsequent displacement of any member(s) of the bargaining unit, the original notice to the Union provided in (i) above shall be considered notice to the Union of any subsequent layoff.

(b) A layoff shall not include a reassignment of an employee from her or his classification or area of assignment who would otherwise be entitled to notice of layoff provided:

(I) reassignments will occur in reverse order of seniority;

(II) the reassignment of the employee is to an appropriate permanent position with the employer having regard to the employees skills, abilities, qualifications and training or training requirements;


(III) the reassignment of the employee does not result in a reduction of the employees wage rate or hours of work;

(IV) the job to which the employee is reassigned is located at the employee’s original work site or at a nearby site in terms of relative accessibility for the employee;

(V) the job to which the employee is reassigned is on the same or substantially similar shift or shift rotation; and

(VI) where more than one employee is to be reassigned in accordance with this provision, the reassigned employees shall be entitled to select from the available appropriate vacancies to which they are being reassigned in order of seniority provided no such selection causes or would cause a layoff or bumping.

The Hospital bears the onus of demonstrating that the foregoing conditions have been met in the event of a dispute. The Hospital shall also reasonably accommodate any reassigned employee who may experience a personal hardship arising from being reassigned in accordance with this provision.

(c) Any vacancy to which an employee is reassigned pursuant to paragraph (b) need not be posted.

(d) Redeployment Committee

At each Hospital a Redeployment Committee will be established not later than two (2) weeks after the notice referred to in 9.08(A)(a) and will meet thereafter as frequently as is necessary.

(i) Committee Mandate

The mandate of the Redeployment Committee is to:

(1) Identify and propose possible alternatives to the proposed layoff(s) or elimination of position(s), including, but not limited to, identifying work which would otherwise be bargaining unit work and is currently work contracted-out by the Hospital which could be performed by bargaining-unit employees who are or would otherwise be laid off;


(2) Identify vacant positions in the Hospital or positions which are currently filled but which will become vacant within a twelve (12) month period and which are either:

(a) within the bargaining unit; or
(b) within another CUPE bargaining unit; or
(c) not covered by a collective agreement.

(3) Identify the retraining needs of workers and facilitate such training for workers who are, or would otherwise be, laid off.

(4) Subject to article 9.11, the Hospital will award vacant positions to employees who are, or would otherwise be laid off, in order of seniority if, with the benefit of up to six (6) months retraining, an employee has become able to meet the normal requirements of the job.

(5) Any dispute relating to the foregoing provisions may be filed as a grievance commencing at Step 2.

(ii) Committee Composition

The Redeployment Committee shall be comprised of equal numbers of representatives of the Hospital and of the Union. The number of representatives will be determined locally. Where for the purposes of HTAP (the Ontario Hospital Training and Adjustment Panel) there is another hospital-wide staffing and redeployment committee created or in existence, Union members of the Redeployment Committee shall serve on any such hospital wide staffing committee established with the same or similar terms of reference, and the number of Union members on such committee will be proportionate to the number of its bargaining unit members at the particular Hospital in relation to other staff groups.

Meetings of the Redeployment Committee shall be held during normal working hours. Time spent attending such meetings shall be deemed to be work time for which the representative(s) shall be paid by the Hospital at his or her regular or premium rate as may be applicable.

Each party shall appoint a co-chair for the Redeployment Committee. Co-chairs shall chair alternative meetings of the Committee and will be jointly responsible for establishing the agenda of the Committee meetings, preparing minutes and writing such correspondence as the Committee may direct.

(iii) Disclosure

The Hospital shall provide to the Redeployment Committee all pertinent staffing and financial information.

(iv) Alternatives

The Redeployment Committee or where there is no consensus, the committee members shall propose alternatives to cutbacks in staffing to the Hospital's Chief Executive Officer and to the Board of Directors.

At the time of submitting any plan concerning rationalization of services and involving the elimination of any position(s) or any layoff(s) to the District Health Council or to the Ministry of Health, the Hospital shall provide a copy, together with accompanying documentation, to the Union.

9.08(B) - RETIREMENT ALLOWANCE

Prior to issuing notice of layoff pursuant to article 9.08(A)(a)(ii) in any classification(s), the Hospital will offer early retirement allowance to a sufficient number of employees eligible for early retirement under HOOPP within the classification(s) in order of seniority, to the extent that the maximum number of employees within a classification who elect early retirement is equivalent to the number of employees within the classification(s) who would otherwise receive
notice of layoff under article 9.08(A)(a)(ii).

An employee who elects an early retirement option shall receive, following completion of the last day of work, a retirement allowance of two (2) weeks' salary for each year of service, plus a prorated amount for any additional partial year of service, to a maximum ceiling of fifty-two (52) weeks' salary.

9.08(C) - VOLUNTARY EXIT OPTION

If after making offers of early retirement, individual layoff notices are still required, prior to issuing those notices the Hospital will offer a voluntary early exit option in accordance with the following conditions:

i) The Hospital will first make offers in the classifications within department(s) where layoffs would otherwise occur. If more employees than are required are interested, the Hospital will make its decision based on seniority.

ii) If insufficient employees in the department affected accept the offer, the Hospital will then extend the offer to employees in the same classification in other departments. If more employees than are required are interested, the Hospital will make its decision based on seniority.

iii) In no case will the Hospital approve an employee’s request under (i) and (ii) above for a voluntary early exit option, if the employees remaining are not qualified to perform the available work.

iv) The number of voluntary early exit options the Hospital approves will not exceed the number of employees in that classification who would otherwise be laid off. The last day of employment for an employee who accepts a voluntary early exit option will be at the Hospital’s discretion and will be no earlier than thirty (30) calendar days immediately following the employee’s written acceptance of the offer.

An employee who elects a voluntary early exit option shall receive, following completion of the last day of work, a separation allowance of two (2) weeks' salary for each year of service, to a maximum of fifty-two (52) weeks' pay.

9.09 LAYOFF AND RECALL

An employee in receipt of notice of layoff pursuant to 9.08(A)(a)(ii) may:

(a) accept the layoff; or

(b) opt to receive a separation allowance as outlined in Article 9.12; or

(c) opt to retire, if eligible under the terms of the Hospitals of Ontario Pension Plan (HOOPP) as outlined in Article 9.08(B); or

(d) displace another employee who has lesser bargaining unit seniority in the same or a lower or an identical-paying classification in the bargaining unit if the employee originally subject to layoff has the ability to meet the normal requirements of the job. An employee so displaced shall be deemed to have been laid off and shall be entitled to notice in accordance with Article 9.08(A)(a).

An employee who chooses to exercise the right to displace another employee with lesser seniority shall advise the Hospital of his or her intention to do so and the position claimed within seven (7) days after receiving the notice of layoff.

For purposes of the operation of clause (d), an identical-paying classification shall include any classification where the straight-time hourly wage rate at the level of service corresponding to that of the laid off employee is within 1% of the laid off employee's straight time hourly wage rate.

(e) In the event that there are no employees with lesser seniority in the same or a lower or identical-paying classification, as defined in this article, a laid-off employee shall have the right to displace another employee with lesser seniority in a higher-paying classification provided they are able to meet the normal requirements of the job, with orientation but without additional training.

(f) In addition, in combined full-time/part-time collective agreements, a full-time employee shall also be entitled to displace another full-time employee with lesser seniority in a higher-paying classification provided that they are able to meet the normal requirements of the job, with orientation but without additional training, when there are no other full-time employees in the same or a lower or similar-paying classification with lesser seniority, prior to being required to displace a part-time employee.

(g) An employee who is subject to layoff other than a layoff of a permanent or long-term nature including a full time employee whose hours of work are, subject to Article 14.01, reduced, shall have the right to accept the layoff or displace another employee in accordance with (a) and (d) above.

(h) No full time employee within the bargaining unit shall be laid off by reason of his/her duties being assigned to one or more part-time employees.

(i) In the event of a layoff of an employee, the Hospital shall pay its share of insured benefits premiums for the duration of the five-month notice period provided for in Article 9.08(A)(a).

(j) The Hospital agrees to post vacancies during the recall period, as per the job posting procedure, allowing employees on recall to participate in the posting procedure. Should the position not be filled via the job posting procedure, an employee shall have opportunity of recall from a layoff to an available opening, in order of seniority, provided he or she has the ability to perform the work.

(k) In determining the ability of an employee to perform the work for the purposes of the paragraphs above, the Hospital shall not act in an arbitrary or unfair manner.

(l) An employee recalled to work in a different classification from which he or she was laid off shall have the privilege of returning to the position held prior to the layoff should it become vacant within six (6) months of being recalled.

(m) No new employees shall be hired until all those laid off have been given an opportunity to return to work and have failed to do so, in accordance with the loss of seniority provision, or have been found unable to perform the work available.

(n) The Hospital shall notify the employee of recall opportunity by registered mail, addressed to the last address on record with the Hospital (which notification shall be deemed to be received on the second day following the date of mailing). The notification shall state the job to which the employee is eligible to be recalled and the date and time at which the employee shall report for work. The employee is solely responsible for his or her proper address being on record with the Hospital.

9.10 - BENEFITS ON LAYOFF
(The following clause is applicable to full time employees only)

In the event of a lay-off of a full-time employee the Hospital shall pay its share of insured benefits premium up to three (3) months from the end of the month in which the lay-off occurs or until the laid off employee is employed elsewhere, whichever occurs first.

9.11 RETRAINING

(a) Retraining for Positions within the Hospital

Where, with the benefit of retraining of up to six (6) months, an employee who has either accepted the layoff or who is unable to displace any other employee could be redeployed to a hospital position identified by the Redeployment Committee in accordance with Article 9.08(A)(d)(i):

(i) Opportunities to fill vacant positions identified by the Hospital Redeployment Committee through retraining shall be offered to employees who apply and would qualify for the position with the available retraining in order of their seniority until the list of any such opportunities is exhausted. Opportunities to fill vacancies outside of CUPE bargaining units may be offered by the Hospital in its discretion.

(ii) The Hospital and the Union will cooperate so that employees who have received notice of permanent layoff and been approved for retraining in order to prevent a layoff will have their work schedules adjusted in order to enable them to participate in the retraining, and scheduling and seniority requirements may by mutual agreement be waived. The Redeployment Committee will seek the availability of any federal or provincial retraining program funds to cover the cost of tuition, books and travel, as well as any wages eligible under the terms of such program.

(iii) Apart from any on-the-job training offered by the Hospital, any employee subject to layoff who may require a leave of absence to undertake retraining in accordance with the foregoing shall be granted an unpaid leave of absence which shall not exceed six (6) months.

(iv) Laid-off employees who are approved for retraining in order to qualify for a vacant position within the Hospital will continue to receive insured benefits.

(b) Placement

Upon successful completion of his or her training period, the Hospital and the Union undertake to waive any restrictions which might otherwise apply, and the employee will be placed in the job identified in 9.11(a)(i).

An employee subject to layoff who applies but later declines to accept a retraining offer or fails to complete the training will remain subject to layoff.

9.12 SEPARATION ALLOWANCES

(a) Where an employee resigns within 30 days after receiving notice of layoff pursuant to article 9.08(A)(a)(ii) that his or her position will be eliminated, he or she shall be entitled to a separation allowance of two (2) weeks' salary for each year of continuous service to a maximum of sixteen (16) weeks' pay, and, on production of receipts from an approved educational program, within twelve (12) months of resignation, may be reimbursed for tuition fees up to a maximum of three thousand ($3,000) dollars.

(b) Where an employee resigns later than 30 days after receiving notice pursuant to Article 9.08(A)(a)(ii) that his or her position will be eliminated, he or she shall be entitled to a separation allowance of four (4) weeks' salary, and, on production of receipts from an approved educational program, within twelve (12) months of resignation, may be reimbursed for tuition fees up to a maximum of one thousand two hundred and fifty ($1,250) dollars.

9.13 TECHNOLOGICAL CHANGE

The Hospital undertakes to notify the Union in advance, so far as practicable, of any technological changes which the Hospital has decided to introduce which will significantly change the status of employees within the bargaining unit.

The Hospital agrees to discuss with the Union the effect of such technological changes on the employment status of employees and to consider practical ways and means of minimizing the adverse affect, if any, upon employees concerned.

Where new or greater skills are required than are already possessed by affected employees under the present methods of operation, such employees shall be given a period of training, with due consideration being given to the employee's age and previous educational background, during which they may perfect or acquire the skills necessitated by the new method of operation. The employer will assume the cost of tuition and travel. There shall be no reduction in wage or salary rates during the training period of any such employee. Training shall be given during the hours of work whenever possible and may extend for up to six months.

Employees with one (1) or more years of continuous service who are subject to lay off under conditions referred to above, will be given notice of the impending change in employment status at the earliest reasonable time in keeping with the notification to the Union as above set forth and the requirements of the applicable law.

9.14 REGISTERED PRACTICAL NURSE PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT/SCOPE OF PRACTICE

Continuous professional development is a hallmark of professional nursing practice. As a self-regulating profession, nursing recognizes the importance of maintaining a dynamic practice environment which includes ongoing learning, the maintenance of competence, career development, career counseling and succession planning. The parties agree that professional development includes a diverse range of activities, including but not limited to formal academic programs; short-term continuing education activities; certification programs; independent learning committee participation. The parties recognize their joint responsibility in and commitment to active participation in the area of professional development, including scope of practice.

Where Registered Practical Nurse professional development is not specifically addressed at any existing joint committee, the Hospital’s Chief Nursing Officer and Human Resources Officer will meet with the Union on a quarterly basis to discuss professional responsibility and scope of practice issues.

In any event, the parties will be guided by the following key principles:

• Professional development will be recognized;
• All Registered Practical Nurses will have access to professional development opportunities;
• Responsibilities for professional development will be shared between the individual and the Hospital;
• Employee needs, Hospital needs and department/program requirements will be considered.


9.15 – WORK-LOADS

(a) The parties agree that patient care is enhanced if concerns relating to professional practice, patient acuity, fluctuating Work-Loads and fluctuating staffing are resolved in a timely and effective manner.

(b) Employees are encouraged to raise their concerns with their immediate supervisor. In the event that the workload concern is not resolved to the employee’s satisfaction, the employee, or group of employees, may submit their concerns to either the Joint Health and Safety Committee (as constituted under the collective agreement’s local appendix) or the Labour Management Committee (as constituted under Article 6.02) through their union representative in a format to be determined by the respective committee.

(c) In the event that an employee or group of employees, covered under the Regulated Health Professions Act (RHPA), are assigned a work-load which is inconsistent with proper patient care, they shall express their concerns to their supervisor. The employee shall complete a “Work-Load Review Form” which shall be provided to the supervisor and to the Union. The Work-Load Review Form will be attached as an Appendix to the collective agreement.

ARTICLE 10 CONTRACTING OUT

10.01 CONTRACTING OUT

The Hospital shall not contract out any work usually performed by members of the bargaining unit if, as a result of such contracting out, a layoff of any employees other than casual part-time employees results from such contracting out.

10.02 CONTRACTING OUT

Notwithstanding the foregoing, the hospital may contract out work usually performed by members of the bargaining unit without such contracting-out constituting a breach of this provision if the hospital provides in its commercial arrangement contracting out the work that the contractor to whom the work is being contracted, and any subsequent such contractor, agrees:

(1) to employ the employees thus displaced from the hospital; and


(2) in doing so to stand, with respect to that work, in the place of the hospital for the purposes of the hospital’s collective agreement with the Union, and to execute into an agreement with the Union to that effect.

In order to ensure compliance with this provision, the hospital agrees that it will withdraw the work from any contractor who has failed to meet the aforesaid terms of the contracting-out arrangement.

10.03 CONTRACTING IN

Further to Article 9.08(A)(d)(i)(1) the parties agree that the Redeployment Committee will immediately undertake a review of any existing sub contract work which would otherwise be bargaining unit work and which may be subject to expiry and open for renegotiation within six (6) months with a view to assessing the practicality and cost-effectiveness of having such work performed within the Hospital by members of the bargaining unit.

ARTICLE 11 WORK OF THE BARGAINING UNIT

11.01 WORK OF THE BARGAINING UNIT

Employees not covered by the terms of this Agreement will not perform duties normally assigned to those employees who are covered by this Agreement, except for the purposes of instruction, experimentation, or in emergencies when regular employees are not readily available.

11.02 – VOLUNTEERS

The use of volunteers to perform bargaining unit work, as covered by this agreement, shall not be expanded beyond the extent of existing practice as of June 1, 1986.

The Hospital shall submit to the Union, at three (3) month intervals, the number of volunteers for the current month and the number of hours worked and the duties performed.

ARTICLE 12 LEAVES OF ABSENCE

12.01 PERSONAL LEAVE

Written request for a personal leave of absence without pay will be considered on an individual basis by the Hospital. Such requests are to be submitted to the employee's immediate supervisor at least four (4) weeks in advance, unless not reasonably possible to give such notice, and a written reply will be given within fourteen (14) days except in cases of emergency in which case a reply will be given as soon as possible. Employees needing personal leave days for appointments with medical practitioners may utilize the personal leave language. Such leave shall not be unreasonably withheld.

12.02 UNION BUSINESS

(a) The Hospital shall grant leave of absence without pay to employees to attend Union conventions, seminars, education classes and other Union business in connection with the administration of the collective agreement provided that such leave will not interfere with the efficient operation of the Hospital. Such leave will not be unreasonably denied.

In requesting such leave of absence for an employee or employees, the Union must give at least fourteen (14) days clear notice in writing to the Hospital, unless not reasonably possible to give such notice.

The cumulative total leave of absence, the number of employees that may be absent at any one time from any one area, and the number of days of absence shall be negotiated locally and are set out in the Local Provisions Appendix.

During such leave of absence, the employee's salary and applicable benefits shall be maintained by the Hospital on the basis of what his normal regular hours of work would have been, provided that the Union reimburses the Hospital in the amount of such salary and applicable benefits within thirty (30) days of billing.

Notwithstanding the above, time spent by the eight (8) Executive Board members and seven (7) Alternate Executive Board members of the Ontario Council of Hospital Unions to fulfill the duties of the position shall be in addition to leave for Union Business under this clause.

Part-time and casual employees will be given full credit for seniority purposes for regularly scheduled hours missed in accordance with this provision.

(b) In addition to the above, a part-time or casual employee who is attending to union business when not regularly scheduled to work shall be deemed to be on union leave and the amount of such leave shall not be deducted from the number of days of absence identified above. Such part-time or casual employee will be credited with seniority for the number of hours of such leave to a maximum of thirty-seven and one-half (37.5) hours per week. The Union will advise the Hospital of the number of such hours.

12.03(A) FULL-TIME POSITION(S) WITH THE UNION
(This clause is applicable to full-time employees only)

Upon application by the Union, in writing, the Hospital shall grant leave of absence, without pay, to an employee elected or appointed to full-time Union office. It is understood that no more than two (2) employees in the bargaining unit may be on such leave at the same time. Such leave shall be for a period of one (1) calendar year from the date of appointment unless extended for a further specific period by agreement of the parties. It is understood that no more than one (1) employee will be from the same unit of the Hospital, subject to operational requirements.

Seniority shall accumulate for employees during such leave on the basis of what his normal regular hours of work would have been. Service shall accumulate for employees during such leave to the maximum provided, if any, under the provisions of the collective agreement. It will become the responsibility of the employee for full payment of any applicable benefits in which the employee is participating during such leave of absence.

The employee shall notify the Hospital of his intention to return to work at least four (4) weeks prior to the date of such return. The employee shall be returned to his former duties on the same shift in the same department and at the appropriate rate of pay, subject to any changes which would have occurred had the employee not been on leave.

Notwithstanding Article 2.01, the Hospital may fill the vacancy resulting from such leave on a temporary basis.

12.03(B) FULL-TIME POSITION(S) WITH THE UNION
(The clause is applicable to part-time employees only)

Upon application by the Union, in writing, the Hospital shall grant leave of absence, without pay, to an employee elected or appointed to full-time Union office. It is understood that no more than two (2) employees in the bargaining unit may be on such leave at the same time. Such leave shall be for a period of one (1) calendar year from the date of appointment unless extended for a further specific period by agreement of the parties. It is understood that no more than one (1) employee will be from the same unit of the Hospital, subject to operational requirements.

Seniority and service shall accrue at seven and one-half (7.5) hours per day to a maximum of thirty-seven and one-half (37.5) hours per week during such leave.

The employee shall notify the Hospital of his intention to return to work at least four (4) weeks prior to the date of such return. The employee shall be returned to his former duties on the same shift in the same department and at the appropriate rate of pay, subject to any changes which would have occurred had the employee not been on leave.

Notwithstanding Article 2.01, the Hospital may fill the vacancy resulting from such leave on a temporary basis.

12.03(C) LEAVE FOR OCHU PRESIDENT AND SECRETARY-TREASURER

Upon application in writing by the Union on behalf of the employee to the Hospital, a leave of absence without pay shall be granted to such employee(s) elected to the positions of the President of the Ontario Council of Hospital Unions or the Secretary-Treasurer of the Ontario Council of Hospital Unions for period(s) of up to two (2) years. It is understood, however, that during such leave the employee(s) shall be deemed to be an employee of the Union.

During such leave of absence seniority and service shall accrue at seven and one-half (7.5) hours per day to a maximum of thirty-seven and one-half (37.5) hours per week. In addition, during such leave of absence, the employee's salary and applicable benefits shall be maintained by the Hospital on the basis of what his normal regular hours of work would have been, provided that the Union reimburses the Hospital in the amount of such salary and applicable benefits within thirty (30) days of billing.

The employee agrees to notify the Hospital of his intention to return to work at least four (4) weeks prior to the date of such return. The employee shall be returned to his former duties on the same shift in the same department and at the appropriate rate of pay, subject to any changes which would have occurred had the employee not been on leave.

Notwithstanding Article 2.01, the Hospital may fill the vacancy resulting from such leave on a temporary basis.

12.04 - BEREAVEMENT LEAVE

Any employee who notifies the Hospital as soon as possible following bereavement will be granted bereavement leave for four (4) consecutive working days off without loss of regular pay from regularly scheduled hours in conjunction with the death of the spouse, child, or parent.

Any employee who notifies the Hospital as soon as possible following a bereavement will be granted bereavement leave for three (3) consecutive working days off without loss of regular pay from regularly scheduled hours in conjunction with the death of the sister, brother, mother-in-law, father-in-law, son-in-law, daughter-in-law, grandparent, grandchild, brother-in-law, sister-in-law or grandparent of spouse.

An employee shall be granted one (1) day bereavement leave without loss of regular pay from regularly scheduled hours to attend the funeral of his or her aunt or uncle, niece or nephew.

The Hospital, in its discretion, may extend such leave with or without pay. Where an employee does not qualify under the above-noted conditions, the Hospital may, nonetheless, grant a paid bereavement leave. For the purpose of bereavement leave, the relationships specified in the preceding clause are deemed to include a common-law spouse and a partner of the same sex.

12.05(A) JURY & WITNESS DUTY
(The following clause is applicable to full time employees only)

If an employee is required to attend jury selection or serve as a juror in any court of law, or is required to attend as a witness in a court proceeding in which the Crown is a party, or is required by subpoena to attend a court of law or coroner's inquest in connection with a case arising from the employee's duties at the Hospital, the employee shall not lose regular pay because of such attendance provided that the employee:

(a) notifies the Hospital immediately on the employee's notification that he will be required to attend at court;

(b) presents proof of service requiring the employee's attendance;

(c) deposits with the Hospital the full amount of compensation received excluding mileage, travelling and meal allowances and an official receipt thereof.

Where a full-time employee is selected for jury duty, for a period in excess of one (1) week, the employee shall be paid for all hours scheduled and not be expected to attend at work. Upon completion of the process the employee shall be returned to that point on their former schedule that is considered appropriate by the Hospital. It is understood and agreed that the local parties may agree to different scheduling arrangements for the first week of jury and witness duty.

In addition to the foregoing, where a full time employee is required by subpoena to attend a court of law or coroner's inquest in connection with a case arising from the employee's duties at the Hospital on his regularly scheduled day off, the Hospital will attempt to reschedule the employee's regular day off. Where the employee's attendance is required during a different shift than he is scheduled to work that day, the Hospital will attempt to reschedule the shift to include the time spent at such hearing. It is understood that any rescheduling shall not result in the payment of any premium pay.

Where the Hospital is unable to reschedule the employee and, as a result, he is required to attend during other than his regularly scheduled paid hours, he shall be paid for all hours actually spent at such hearing at his straight time hourly rate subject to (a), (b) and (c) above.

12.05(B) - JURY & WITNESS DUTY
(This clause is applicable to part-time employees only)

If an employee is required to attend jury selection or serve as a juror in any court of law, or is required to attend as a witness in a court proceeding in which the Crown is a party, or is required by subpoena to attend a court of law or coroner's inquest in connection with a case arising from the employee's duties at the Hospital, the employee shall not lose regular pay because of such attendance provided that the employee:

(a) notifies the Hospital immediately on the employee's notification that he will be required to attend at court;

(b) presents proof of service requiring the employee's attendance;

(c) deposits with the Hospital the full amount of compensation received excluding mileage, travelling and meal allowances and an official receipt thereof.

Where a part-time employee is selected for jury duty, for a period in excess of one (1) week, the employee shall be paid for all hours scheduled and not be expected to attend at work. Upon completion of the process the employee shall be returned to that point on their former schedule that is considered appropriate by the Hospital. It is understood and agreed that the local parties may agree to different scheduling arrangements for the first week of jury and witness duty.

In addition to the foregoing, where a part-time employee is required by subpoena to attend a court of law or coroner's inquest in connection with a case arising from the employee's duties at the Hospital on his regularly scheduled day off, he shall be paid for all hours actually spent at such hearings at his regular straight time hourly rate subject to (a), (b) and (c) above.

12.06(A) PREGNANCY LEAVE
(The following clause is applicable to full time employees only)

(a) Pregnancy leave will be granted in accordance with the provisions of the Employment Standards Act, except where amended in this provision. The service requirement for eligibility for pregnancy leave shall be thirteen (13) weeks of continuous service.

(b) The employee shall give written notification at least two (2) weeks in advance of the date of commencement of such leave and the expected date of return. At such time she shall also furnish the Hospital with the certificate of a legally qualified medical practitioner stating the expected birth date.

(c) The employee shall reconfirm her intention to return to work on the date originally approved in subsection (b) above by written notification received by the Hospital at least two (2) weeks in advance thereof.

(d) Effective on confirmation by the Canada Employment Insurance Commission of the appropriateness of the Hospital's Supplementary Unemployment Benefit (SUB) Plan, an employee who is on pregnancy leave as provided under this Agreement who has applied for and is in receipt of Employment Insurance pregnancy benefits pursuant to Section 22 of the Employment Insurance Act shall be paid a supplemental unemployment benefit for a period not exceeding fifteen (15) weeks. The supplement shall be equivalent to the difference between ninety-three percent (93%) of her normal weekly earnings and the sum of her weekly unemployment insurance benefits and any other earnings. Receipt by the Hospital of the employee's unemployment insurance cheque stubs shall constitute proof that she is in receipt of Employment Insurance pregnancy benefits.

The employee's normal weekly earnings shall be determined by multiplying her regular hourly rate on her last day worked prior to the commencement of the leave times her normal weekly hours plus any wage increase or salary increment that she would be entitled to receive if she were not on pregnancy leave.

In addition to the foregoing, the Hospital will pay the employee ninety-three percent (93%) of her normal weekly earnings during the first two (2) week period of the leave while waiting to receive Employment Insurance benefits.

The employee does not have any vested right except to receive payments for the covered unemployment period. The plan provides that payment in respect of guaranteed annual remuneration or in respect of deferred remuneration or severance pay benefits are not reduced or increased by payments received under the plan.

(e) Credits for service and seniority shall accumulate for a period of up to seventeen (17) weeks while an employee is on pregnancy leave.

(f) The Hospital will continue to pay its share of the contributions of the subsidized employee benefits, including pension, in which the employee is participating for a period of up to seventeen (17) weeks while the employee is on pregnancy leave.

(g) Subject to any changes to the employee's status which would have occurred had she not been on pregnancy leave, the employee shall be reinstated to her former duties, on the same shift in the same department, and at the same rate of pay.

12.06(B) PREGNANCY LEAVE
(The following clause is applicable to part-time employees only)

(a) Pregnancy leave will be granted in accordance with the provisions of the Employment Standards Act, except where amended in this provision. The service requirement for eligibility for pregnancy leave shall be thirteen (13) weeks of continuous service.

(b) The employee shall give written notification at least two (2) weeks in advance of the date of commencement of such leave and the expected date of return. At such time she shall also furnish the Hospital with the certificate of a legally qualified medical practitioner stating the expected birth date.

(c) The employee shall reconfirm her intention to return to work on the date originally approved in subsection (b) above by written notification received by the Hospital at least two (2) weeks in advance thereof.

(d) Effective on confirmation by the Canada Employment Insurance Commission of the appropriateness of the Hospital's Supplementary Unemployment Benefit (SUB) Plan, an employee who is on pregnancy leave as provided under this Agreement who has applied for and is in receipt of Employment Insurance pregnancy benefits pursuant to Section 23 of the Employment Insurance Act, shall be paid a supplemental unemployment benefit for a period not exceeding fifteen (15) weeks. The supplement shall be equivalent to the difference between ninety-three percent (93%) of her normal weekly earnings and the sum of her weekly unemployment insurance benefits and any other earnings. Receipt by the Hospital of the employee's unemployment insurance cheque stubs shall constitute proof that she is in receipt of Employment Insurance pregnancy benefits.

The employee's normal weekly earnings shall be determined by multiplying her regular hourly rate on her last day worked prior to the commencement of the leave times her normal weekly hours plus any wage increase or salary increment that she would be entitled to receive if she were not on pregnancy leave.

In addition to the foregoing, the Hospital will pay the employee ninety-three percent (93%) of her normal weekly earnings during the first two (2) week period of the leave while waiting to receive Employment Insurance benefits.

The employee does not have any vested right except to receive payments for the covered unemployment period. The plan provides that payment in respect of guaranteed annual remuneration or in respect of deferred remuneration or severance pay benefits are not reduced or increased by payments received under the plan.

(e) Credits for service and seniority shall accumulate for a period of up to seventeen (17) weeks while an employee is on pregnancy leave on the basis of what the employee's normal regular hours of work would have been.

(f) The Hospital will continue to pay the percentage in lieu of benefits and its share of pension contributions during the period of pregnancy leave. The Hospital will register those benefits as part of the Supplemental Unemployment Benefit Plan with the Canada Employment Insurance Commission.

(g) Subject to any changes to the employee's status which would have occurred had she not been on pregnancy leave, the employee shall be reinstated to her former duties, on the same shift in the same department, and at the same rate of pay.

12.07(A) PARENTAL LEAVE
(The following clause is applicable to full time employees only)

(a) Parental leaves will be granted in accordance with the provisions of the Employment Standards Act, except where amended in this provision. The service requirement for eligibility for parental leave shall be thirteen (13) weeks of continuous service.

(b) An employee, who qualifies for parental leave, other than an adoptive parent, shall give written notification of at least two (2) weeks in advance of the date of the commencement of such leave and the expected date of return.

(c) For the purposes of this Article, parent shall be defined to include a person with whom a child is placed for adoption and a person who is in a relationship of some permanence with a parent of a child and who intends to treat the child as his or her own.

(d) An employee who is an adoptive parent shall advise the Hospital as far in advance as possible of having qualified to adopt a child, and shall request the leave of absence, in writing, upon receipt of confirmation of the pending adoption. If, because of late receipt of confirmation of the pending adoption, the employee finds it impossible to request the leave of absence in writing, the request may be made verbally and subsequently verified in writing.

An employee shall reconfirm his or her intention to return to work on the date originally approved in subsection (b) above by written notification received by the Hospital at least two (2) weeks in advance thereof.

(e) Effective on confirmation by the Canada Employment Insurance Commission of the appropriateness of the Hospital's Supplemental Unemployment Benefit (SUB) Plan, an employee who is on parental leave as provided under this Agreement who has applied for and is in receipt of Employment Insurance parental benefits pursuant to Section 22 of the Employment Insurance Act, shall be paid a supplemental unemployment benefit for a period not exceeding ten (10) weeks. That benefit shall be equivalent to the difference between ninety-three percent (93%) of the employee's normal weekly earnings and the sum of his or her weekly Employment Insurance benefits and any other earnings. Receipt by the Hospital of the employee's employment insurance cheque stub will serve as proof that the employee is in receipt of unemployment parental benefits.

The employee's normal weekly earnings shall be determined by multiplying the employee's regular hourly rate on his or her last day worked prior to the commencement of the leave times the employee's normal weekly hours, plus any wage increase or salary increment that the employee would be entitled to if he or she were not on parental leave.

In addition to the foregoing, the Hospital shall pay the employee ninety-three percent (93%) of his or her normal weekly earnings during the first two (2) week period of the leave while waiting to receive Employment Insurance benefits.

The employee does not have any vested right except to receive payments for the covered unemployment period. The plan provides that payment in respect of guaranteed annual remuneration or in respect of deferred remuneration or severance pay benefits are not reduced or increased by payments received under the plan.

(f) Credits for service and seniority shall accumulate for a period of up to thirty-five (35) weeks after the parental leave began, if the employee also took pregnancy leave, and thirty-seven (37) weeks after the parental leave began otherwise, while the employee is on parental leave.

(g) The Hospital will continue to pay its share of the premiums of the subsidized employee benefits, including pension, in which the employee is participating for a period of up to thirty-five (35) weeks after the parental leave began, if the employee also took pregnancy leave, and thirty-seven (37) weeks after the parental leave began otherwise, while the employee is on parental leave.

(h) Subject to any changes to the employee's status which would have occurred had he or she not been on parental leave, the employee shall be reinstated to her former duties, on the same shift in the same department, and at the same rate of pay.

12.07(B) - PARENTAL LEAVE
(The following clause is applicable to part-time employees only)

(a) Parental leaves will be granted in accordance with the provisions of the Employment Standards Act, except where amended in this provision. The service requirement for eligibility for parental leave shall be thirteen (13) weeks of continuous service.

(b) An employee, who qualifies for parental leave, other than an adoptive parent, shall give written notification of at least two (2) weeks in advance of the date of the commencement of such leave and the expected date of return.

(c) For the purposes of this article, parent shall be defined to include a person with whom a child is placed for adoption and a person who is in a relationship of some permanence with a parent of a child and who intends to treat the child as his or her own.

(d) An employee who is an adoptive parent shall advise the Hospital as far in advance as possible of having qualified to adopt a child, and shall request the leave of absence, in writing, upon receipt of confirmation of the pending adoption. If, because of late receipt of confirmation of the pending adoption, the employee finds it impossible to request the leave of absence in writing, the request may be made verbally and subsequently verified in writing. An employee shall reconfirm his or her intention to return to work on the date originally approved in subsection (b) above by written notification received by the Hospital at least two (2) weeks in advance thereof.

(e) Effective on confirmation by the Canada Employment Insurance Commission of the appropriateness of the Hospital's Supplemental Unemployment Benefit (SUB) Plan, an employee who is on parental leave as provided under this Agreement who has applied for and is in receipt of Employment Insurance parental benefits pursuant to Section 23 of the Employment Insurance Act, shall be paid a supplemental unemployment benefit for a period not exceeding ten (10) weeks. That benefit shall be equivalent to the difference between ninety-three percent (93%) of the employee's normal weekly earnings and the sum of his or her weekly employment insurance benefits and any other earnings. Receipt by the Hospital of the employee's employment insurance cheque stub will serve as proof that the employee is in receipt of unemployment parental benefits.

The employee's normal weekly earnings shall be determined by multiplying the employee's regular hourly rate on his or her last day worked prior to the commencement of the leave times the employee's normal weekly hours, plus any wage increase or salary increment that the employee would be entitled to if he or she were not on parental leave.

In addition to the foregoing the Hospital shall pay the employee ninety-three percent (93%) of his or her normal weekly earnings during the first two (2) week period of the leave while waiting to receive Employment Insurance benefits.

The employee does not have any vested right except to receive payments for the covered unemployment period. The plan provides that payment in respect of guaranteed annual remuneration or in respect of deferred remuneration or severance pay benefits are not reduced or increased by payments received under the plan.

(f) Credits for service and seniority shall accumulate for a period of up to thirty-five (35) weeks after the parental leave began, if the employee also took pregnancy leave, and thirty-seven (37) weeks after the parental leave began otherwise, while the employee is on parental leave on the basis of what the employee's normal regular hours of work would have been.

(g) The Hospital will continue to pay the percentage in lieu of benefits and its share of the pension contribution for a period of up to ten (10) weeks while the employee is on parental leave. The Hospital will register these benefits with the Unemployment Benefit Plan.

(h) Subject to any changes to the employee's status which would have occurred had he or she not been on parental leave, the employee shall be reinstated to her former duties, on the same shift in the same department, and at the same rate of pay.

12.08 - EDUCATION LEAVE

If required by the Hospital, an employee shall be entitled to leave of absence with pay and with full credit for service and seniority and benefits to take courses and to write examinations to upgrade his or her employment qualifications. Where employees are required by the Hospital to take courses to upgrade or acquire new employment qualifications, the Hospital shall pay the full costs associated with the courses.

Subject to operational requirements, the Hospital will make every reasonable effort to grant requests for necessary changes to an employee's schedule to enable attendance at a recognized up grading course or seminar related to employment with the Hospital.

Subject to operational requirements, the Hospital will make every reasonable effort to grant requests for an employee to take an educational leave without pay and without loss of seniority of up to twelve (12) months for training related to the employee’s employment at the Hospital.

12.09 - PRE-PAID LEAVE PLAN

The Hospital agrees to introduce a pre-paid leave program, funded solely by the employee subject to the following terms and conditions:

(a) The plan is available to employees wishing to spread four (4) years' salary over a five (5) year period, in accordance with Part LXVIII of the Income Tax Regulations, Section 6801, to enable them to take a one (1) year leave of absence following the four (4) years of salary deferral.

(b) The employee must make written application to the Hospital at least six (6) months prior to the intended commencement date of the program (i.e. the salary deferral portion), stating the intended purpose of the leave.

(c) The number of employees that may be absent at any one time shall be determined between the local parties. The year for purposes of the program shall be September 1 of one year to August 31 the following year or such other twelve (12) month period as may be agreed upon by the employee, the local Union and the Hospital.

(d) Where there are more applications than spaces allotted, seniority shall govern.

(e) During the four (4) years of salary deferral, 20% of the employee's gross annual earnings will be deducted and held for the employee and will not be accessible to the employee until the year of the leave or upon withdrawal from the plan.

(f) The manner in which the deferred salary is held shall be at the discretion of the Hospital.

(g) All deferred salary, plus accrued interest, if any, shall be paid to the employee at the commencement of the leave or in accordance with such other payment schedule as may be agreed upon between the Hospital and the employee.

(h) All benefits shall be kept whole during the four (4) years of salary deferral. During the year of the leave, seniority will accumulate. Service for the purpose of vacation and salary progression and other benefits will be retained but will not accumulate during the period of leave. The employee shall become responsible for the full payment of premiums for any health and welfare benefits in which the employee is participating. Contributions to the Hospitals of Ontario Pension Plan will be in accordance with the Plan. The employee will not be eligible to participate in the disability income plan during the year of the leave.

(i) An employee may withdraw from the plan at any time during the deferral portion provided three (3) months notice is given to the Hospital. Deferred salary, plus accrued interest, if any, will be returned to the employee within a reasonable period of time.

(j) If the employee terminates employment, the deferred salary held by the Hospital plus accrued interest, if any, will be returned to the employee within a reasonable period of time. In case of the employee's death, the funds will be paid to the employee's estate.

(k) The Hospital will endeavour to find a temporary replacement for the employee as far in advance as practicable. If the Hospital is unable to find a suitable replacement, it may postpone the leave. The Hospital will give the employee as much notice as is reasonably possible. The employee will have the option of remaining in the Plan and rearranging the leave at a mutually agreeable time or of withdrawing from the Plan and having the deferred salary, plus accrued interest, if any, paid out to the employee within a reasonable period of time.

(l) The employee will be reinstated to his or her former position unless the position has been discontinued, in which case the employee shall be given a comparable job.

(m) Final approval for entry into the pre-paid leave program will be subject to the employee entering into a formal agreement with the Hospital in order to authorize the Hospital to make the appropriate deductions from the employee's pay. Such agreement will include:

(i) A statement that the employee is entering the pre-paid leave program in accordance with this Article of the collective agreement.

(ii) The period of salary deferral and the period for which the leave is requested.

(iii) The manner in which the deferred salary is to be held.

The letter of application from the employee to the Hospital to enter the prepaid leave program will be appended to and form part of the written agreement.

12.10 – MEDICAL CARE AND EMERGENCY LEAVE

An employee is entitled to a leave of absence without pay because of any of the following:

1. A personal illness, injury or medical emergency.
2. The death, illness, injury or medical emergency of an individual described in this Article.
3. An urgent matter that concerns an individual described in this Article.

For the purposes of this Article, the individuals referred to in this Article are:

- the employee’s spouse
- a parent, step-parent or foster parent of the employee or the employee’s spouse
- a child, step-child or foster child of the employee or the employee’s spouse
- a grandparent, step-grandparent, grandchild or step-grandchild of the employee or of the employee’s spouse
- the spouse of a child of the employee
- the employee’s brother or sister
- a relative of the employee who is dependent on the employee for care or assistance.

An employee who wishes to take leave under this section shall advise his or her Hospital that he or she will be doing so. If the employee must begin the leave before advising the Hospital, the employee shall advise the Hospital of the leave as soon as possible after beginning it.

An employee is entitled to take a total of 10 days’ leave under this section each year. If an employee takes any part of a day as leave under this section, the Hospital may deem the employee to have taken one day’s leave on that day for the purposes of this Article. The Hospital may require an employee who takes leave under this section to provide evidence reasonable in the circumstances that the employee is entitled to the leave.

Upon the conclusion of an employee’s leave under this Article, the Hospital shall reinstate the employee to the position the employee most recently held with the Hospital, if it still exists, or to a comparable position, if it does not.

12.11 –COMPASSIONATE CARE LEAVE

(a) Compassionate care leave will be granted to an employee for up to eight (8) weeks within a twenty-six (26) week period to provide care or support to a family member who is at risk of dying within that 26-week period in accordance with section 49.1 of the Employment Standards Act, 2000.

(b) An employee who is on compassionate care leave shall continue to accumulate seniority and service.

(c) Subject to any changes to the employee's status which would have occurred had
he or she not been on compassionate care leave, the employee shall be reinstated to her former duties, on the same shift in the same department, and at the same rate of pay.

(d) The employee and the Hospital will continue to pay their respective shares of the
benefits and pension premiums.

ARTICLE 13 SICK LEAVE, INJURY AND DISABILITY

There are two different versions of Article 13.01, depending upon whether the local parties have agreed to HOODIP (1992 booklets) or equivalent, or have some other sick leave/LTD arrangements.

Select the appropriate version of Article 13.01 as follows:

If the parties have agreed to HOODIP (1992 booklets) or equivalent or if the Hospital and the local union mutually agree to replace the existing accumulating sick leave plan with HOODIP or equivalent, insert the following provision as Article 13.01. (In the event of such mutual agreement to replace the existing plan with HOODIP or equivalent, the provision below will become effective on the first of the month agreed to by the local parties and will replace any existing accumulating sick leave program or plan.)

13.01 – HOODIP
(The following clause is applicable to full time employees only)

a) The Hospital will assume total responsibility for providing and funding a short-term sick leave plan equivalent to that described in the August, 1992 booklet (Part A) Hospitals of Ontario Disability Income Plan Brochure.

The Hospital will pay 75% of the billed premium towards coverage of eligible employees under the long-term disability portion of the Plan (HOODIP or an equivalent plan as described in the August, 1992 booklet (Part B)), the employee paying the balance of the billed premium through payroll deduction. For the purpose of transfer to the short- term portion of the disability program, employees on the payroll as of the effective date of the transfer with three (3) months or more of service shall be deemed to have three (3) months of service. For the purpose of transfer to the long-term portion of the disability program, employees on the active payroll as of the effective date of the transfer with one (1) year or more of service shall be deemed to have one (1) year of service.

b) Effective the first of the month following the transfer all existing sick leave plans in the affected Hospitals shall be terminated and any provisions relating to such plans shall be null and void under the respective Collective Agreements except as to those provisions relating to pay out of unused sick leave benefits which are specifically dealt with hereinafter.

c) Existing sick leave credits for each employee shall be converted to a sick leave bank to the credit of the employee. The "sick leave bank" shall be utilized to:

(1) supplement payment for lost straight time wages on sick leave days under the new program which would otherwise be at less than full wages or no wages and,

(2) where a pay out provision existed under the former sick leave plan in the Collective Agreement, pay out on termination of employment shall be that portion of any unused sick leave days under the former conditions relating to pay out,

(3) where, as of the effective date of transfer, an employee does not have the required service to qualify for pay out on termination, his existing sick leave credits as of that date shall nevertheless be converted to a sick leave bank in accordance with the foregoing and he shall be entitled, on termination, to that portion of any unused sick leave days providing he subsequently achieves the necessary service to qualify him for pay out under the conditions relating to such pay out.

(4) an employee who, as of the effective date of transfer, has accumulated sick leave credits and is prevented from working for the Hospital on account of an occupational illness or accident that is recognized by the Workplace Safety & Insurance Board as compensable within the meaning of the Workplace Safety & Insurance Act, the Hospital, on application from the employee will supplement the award made by the Workplace Safety & Insurance Board for loss of wages to the employee by such amount that the award of the Workplace Safety & Insurance Board for loss of wages, together with the supplementation of the Hospital, will equal 100% of the employee's net earnings, to the limit of the employee's accumulated sick leave credits.

d) There shall be no pay deduction from an employee's regular scheduled shift when an employee has completed any portion of the shift prior to going on sick leave benefits or WSIB benefits.

e) The Hospital further agrees to pay employees an amount equal to any loss of benefits under HOODIP for the first two (2) days of the fourth and subsequent period of absence in any calendar year.

f) Any dispute which may arise concerning an employee's entitlement to any benefits referred to in Article 13.01, including HOODIP and equivalents, may be subject to the grievance and arbitration under the provisions of this collective agreement.

The Union agrees that it will encourage an employee to utilize the Medical Appeals Process provided under the plan, if any, to resolve disputes.

g) A copy of the current HOODIP plan text or, where applicable, the master policy of the current HOODIP equivalent, shall be provided to the Union.

h) The Hospital shall pay the full cost of any medical certificate required of an employee.

i) The short-term sick leave plan shall be registered with the Employment Insurance Commission (EIC). The employee’s share of the employer’s unemployment insurance premium reduction will be retained by the Hospital towards offsetting the cost of the benefit improvements contained in this agreement.”

Note: Provisions 13.c)(3) and 13.c)(4) shall apply for the short and long-term disability plan to those employees in the full time Collective Agreements who are now on an accumulating sick leave plan. Any Medical/Dental Care provisions currently in the agreement shall be removed.

If the parties have not agreed to HOODIP (1992 booklets) or equivalent (i.e. an accumulating plan currently exists), insert the following provision as Article 13.01:

13.01 – SICK LEAVE
(The following clause is applicable to full time employees only)

Insert existing sick leave provisions as the first part of this provision.

Insert the following language as the second part of this provision.

“The Hospital shall pay the full cost of any medical certificate required of an employee.”

Insert the following as the third part of this provision.

Where an employee is prevented from working for the Hospital on account of an occupational illness or accident that is recognized by the Workplace Safety & Insurance Board as compensable within the meaning of the Workplace Safety & Insurance Act, the Hospital, on application from the employee will utilize the employee's accumulated sick leave credits to supplement the award made by the Workplace Safety & Insurance Board for loss of wages to the employee by such amount that the award of the Workplace Safety & Insurance Board for loss of wages, together with the supplementation of the Hospital, will equal 100% of the employee's net earnings, to the limit of the employee's accumulated sick leave credits. Where a WSIB top-up is currently provided from general revenue, it will be provided on the same basis except that it will continue to be provided from general revenue.

13.02 – INJURY PAY

If an employee is injured on the job and his supervisor excuses him from further duty for the balance of his shift, the employee's regular rate of pay shall continue for the balance of that shift and there shall be no deduction from sick leave or other credits.

13.03 – PAYMENT PENDING DETERMINATION OF WSIB CLAIMS (FT)

An employee who is absent from work as a result of an illness or injury sustained at work and who has been awaiting approval of claim for WSIB benefits for a period longer than one complete pay period may apply to the Hospital for payment equivalent to the lesser of the benefit she would receive from WSIB benefits if her claim was approved, or the benefit to which she would be entitled under the short term sick leave plan. Payment will be provided only if the employee provides evidence of disability satisfactory to the Hospital and a written undertaking satisfactory to the Hospital that any payments will be refunded to the Hospital following final determination of the claim by the Workplace Safety & Insurance Board. If the claim for WSIB benefits is not approved, the monies paid as an advance will be applied towards the benefits to which the employee would be entitled under the short-term sick leave plan. Any payment under this provision will continue for a maximum of fifteen (15) weeks.

ARTICLE 14 HOURS OF WORK

14.01 DAILY & WEEKLY HOURS OF WORK

Any provision related to the specification of the number of daily & weekly hours of work that existed in the hospital's expiring collective agreement, will be continued as Article 14.01.

14.02(A) REST PERIODS
(The following clause is applicable to full time employees only)

The Hospital will schedule one fifteen (15) minute rest period for each full scheduled half shift.

14.02(B) - REST PERIODS (PT)
(This clause is applicable to part-time employees only)

Part-time employees shall be entitled to a paid rest period of fifteen (15) minutes for each three and three-quarter (3 3/4) hours of work.

14.03 ADDITIONAL REST PERIODS

When an employee performs authorized overtime work of at least three (3) hours duration, the Hospital will schedule a rest period of fifteen (15) minutes duration.

14.04 EXTENDED TOURS

Extended tour provisions may be negotiated by the parties at the local level.

ARTICLE 15 PREMIUM PAYMENT

15.01 DEFINITION OF REGULAR STRAIGHT TIME RATE OF PAY

The regular straight time rate of pay is that prescribed in wage schedule of the Collective Agreement.

15.02 DEFINITION OF OVERTIME

Any provision related to the definition of overtime hours that existed in the hospital's expiring collective agreement, will be continued as Article 15.02.

15.03 OVERTIME PREMIUM AND NO PYRAMIDING

Subject to any superior conditions, the overtime rate shall be time and one-half (1-1/2) the employee's straight-time hourly rate.

Where an employee is required to work additional overtime contiguous to an overtime shift within a twenty-four (24) hour period, the employee will be compensated at the rate of double time his or her straight time hourly rate for all additional contiguous overtime hours worked.

Overtime premium will not be duplicated nor pyramided nor shall other premiums be duplicated nor pyramided nor shall the same hours worked be counted as part of the normal work week and also as hours for which the overtime premium is paid.

15.04 TIME OFF IN LIEU OF OVERTIME

Employees who work overtime will not be required to take time off in regular hours to make up for overtime worked.

Time off in lieu may be taken on a mutually agreed upon basis between the employee and the Hospital, such time off will be the equivalent of the premium rate the employee has earned for working overtime. The Hospital shall revert to payment of premium rate if time off is not taken within ninety (90) calendar days of the work week in which the overtime was earned or, with the employee’s agreement, within 12 months of that work week.

15.05 REPORTING PAY

Employees who report for any scheduled shift will be guaranteed at least four (4) hours of work, or if no work is available will be paid at least four (4) hours except when work is not available due to conditions beyond the control of the Hospital. The reporting allowance outlined as herein shall not apply whenever an employee has received prior notice not to report for work. Part-time employees scheduled to work less than seven and one-half (7-1/2) hours per day will receive a pro-rated amount of reporting pay.

15.06 CALL-BACK

Where employees are called back to work after having completed a regular shift, and prior to the commencement of their next regular shift, they shall receive a minimum of four (4) hours of work or four (4) hours pay at the rate of time and one-half (1-1/2) their regular hourly earnings. Superior provisions shall remain.

15.07 – STANDBY

An employee who is required to remain available for duty on standby, outside the normal working hours for that particular employee, shall receive standby pay in the amount of $3.20 per hour for all hours on standby.

Standby pay shall, however, cease where an employee is called into work under Article 15.06 above and works during the period of standby.

15.08 TEMPORARY TRANSFER

Where an employee is assigned temporarily to perform the duties and assume the responsibilities of a higher paying position in the bargaining unit, he shall be paid the rate in the higher salary range immediately above his current rate for all hours worked in the higher paying position.

Where a Hospital temporarily assigns an employee to carry out the assigned responsibilities of a classification outside the bargaining unit, the employee shall receive an allowance of $4.00 for each shift from the time of the assignment.

15.09 - SHIFT AND WEEKEND PREMIUM

Employees shall be paid a shift premium of one dollar and five cents ($1.05) per hour for all hours worked where the majority of their scheduled hours fall between 1500 and 0700 hours.

The same one dollar and five cents ($1.05) per hour will be paid as weekend premium for all hours worked between 2400 hours Friday and 2400 hours Sunday, or such other 48-hour period as may be agreed upon by the local parties.

Effective September 29, 2010, employees shall be paid a shift premium of one dollar and ten cents ($1.10) per hour for all hours worked where the majority of their scheduled hours fall between 1500 and 0700 hours.

The same one dollar and ten cents ($1.10) per hour will be paid as weekend premium for all hours worked between 2400 hours Friday and 2400 hours Sunday, or such other 48-hour period as may be agreed upon by the local parties.

Effective September 29, 2011, employees shall be paid a shift premium of one dollar and fifteen cents ($1.15) per hour for all hours worked where the majority of their scheduled hours fall between 1500 and 0700 hours.

The same one dollar and fifteen cents ($1.15) per hour will be paid as weekend premium for all hours worked between 2400 hours Friday and 2400 hours Sunday, or such other 48-hour period as may be agreed upon by the local parties.

Effective September 29, 2012, employees shall be paid a shift premium of one dollar and twenty cents ($1.20) per hour for all hours worked where the majority of their scheduled hours fall between 1500 and 0700 hours.

The same one dollar and twenty cents ($1.20) per hour will be paid as weekend premium for all hours worked between 2400 hours Friday and 2400 hours Sunday, or such other 48-hour period as may be agreed upon by the local parties.

ARTICLE 16 HOLIDAYS

16.01 NUMBER OF HOLIDAYS
(The following clause is applicable to full time employees only)

There shall be twelve (12) holidays and these holidays are set out in the Local Provisions Appendix.

Should the Hospital be required to observe an additional paid holiday as a result of legislation, it is understood that one of the existing holidays recognized by the Hospital shall be established as the legislated holiday after discussion with the Union, so that the Hospital's obligation to provide the number of paid holidays as noted above remains unchanged.

16.02 DEFINITION OF HOLIDAY PAY AND QUALIFIERS
(The following clause is applicable to full time employees only)

Holiday pay will be computed on the basis of the employee's regular straight time hourly rate of pay times the employee's normal daily hours of work.

In order to qualify for holiday pay for any holiday, as set out in the Local Provisions Appendix, or to qualify for a lieu day an employee must complete her scheduled shift on each of the working days immediately prior to and following the holiday except where absence on one or both of the said qualifying days is due to a satisfactory reason.

An employee who was scheduled to work on a holiday, as set out in the Local Provisions Appendix, and is absent shall not be entitled to holiday pay or to a lieu day to which she would otherwise be entitled unless such absence was due to a satisfactory reason.

An employee who qualifies to receive pay for any holiday or a lieu day will not be entitled, in the event of illness, to receive sick pay in addition to holiday pay or a lieu day in respect of the same day.

16.03(A) - PAYMENT FOR WORKING ON A HOLIDAY
(The following clause is applicable to full-time employees only)

If an employee is required to work on any of the holidays set out in the local Appendix the employee shall be paid at the rate of time and one-half (1-1/2) her regular straight time hourly rate of pay for all hours worked on such holiday subject to Article 16.04. In addition, if the employee qualifies in accordance with Article 16.02 above the employee will receive a lieu day off with pay in the amount of the employee's regular straight time hourly rate of pay times the employee's normal daily hours of work.

Other provisions if any, relating to the scheduling of lieu days or relating to the payment of holiday pay instead of receiving a lieu day off are located in the Local Provisions Appendix.

16.03(B) - PAYMENT FOR WORKING ON A HOLIDAY
(The following clause is applicable to part-time employees only)

The holidays listed in the part-time local Appendix for the purposes of Article 16.03(b) shall be the same holidays as are listed in the full-time Local Provisions Appendix.

If an employee is required to work on any of the holidays set out in the local Appendix the employee shall be paid at the rate of time and one-half (1-1/2) her regular straight time hourly rate of pay for all hours worked on such holiday.

16.04 PAYMENT FOR WORKING OVERTIME ON A HOLIDAY

Where an employee is required to work authorized overtime in excess of his regularly scheduled hours on a paid holiday, such employee shall receive twice (2x) his regular straight time hourly rate for such authorized overtime.

ARTICLE 17 VACATIONS

Subject to any superior conditions:

An employee who has completed the following number of continuous years of service:
But less than the following number of continuous years of service:
Is entitled to the following number of weeks of annual vacation with pay:

1

2
2
2
5
3
5
13
4
13
21
5
21
28
6
28

7


Effective September 29, 2012, the vacation entitlement will be as follows:

Subject to any superior conditions:

An employee who has completed the following number of continuous years of service:
But less than the following number of continuous years of service:
Is entitled to the following number of weeks of annual vacation with pay:

1

2
2
2
5
3
5
12
4
12
20
5
20
28
6
28

7


Vacation pay shall be calculated on the basis of the employee's regular straight time rate of pay times their normal weekly hours of work, subject to the application of Article 9.04, Effect of Absence.

17.01(B) ‑ PART-TIME ENTITLEMENT, QUALIFIERS AND CALCULATION OF PAYMENT
(The following clause is applicable to part-time employees only)

Any provision related to part-time qualifiers and calculation of payment that existed in the hospital's expiring collective agreement will be continued in Article 17.01(b).

Subject to any superior conditions:

An employee who has completed the following number of continuous hours of service:
But less than the following number of continuous hours of service:
Is entitled to the following percentage of vacation pay, plus the equivalent time off:

Less than 3,450


4%
3,450
8,625
6%
8,625
22,425
8%
22,425
36,225
10%
36,225
48,300
12%
48,300

14%



Effective September 29, 2012, the vacation entitlement will be as follows:

Subject to any superior conditions:

An employee who has completed the following number of continuous hours of service:
But less than the following number of continuous hours of service:
Is entitled to the following percentage of vacation pay, plus the equivalent time off:

Less than 3,450


4%
3,450
8,625
6%
8,625
20,700
8%
20,700
34,500
10%
34,500
48,300
12%
48,300

14%



Progression on Vacation Schedule (Part-Time)

Part-time employees, including casual employees, shall accumulate service for the purpose of progression on the vacation scale, on the basis of one year for each 1725 hours worked.

17.02 ‑ WORK DURING VACATION

Should an employee who has commenced his scheduled vacation and agrees upon request by the Hospital to return to perform work during the vacation period, the employee shall be paid at the rate of one and one-half (1-1/2) times his basic straight time rate for all hours so worked. To replace the originally scheduled days on which such work was performed, the employee will receive one (1) vacation lieu day off for each day on which he has so worked.

17.03 ‑ ILLNESS DURING VACATION
(The following clause is applicable to full‑time employees only)

Where an employee's scheduled vacation is interrupted due to serious illness, which either commenced prior to or during the scheduled vacation period, the period of such illness shall be considered sick leave.

Serious illness is defined as an illness which requires the employee to receive on-going medical care and/or treatments resulting in either hospitalization or which would confine the employee to their residence or to bed rest for more than three days.

The portion of the employee's vacation which is deemed to be sick leave under the above provisions will not be counted against the employee's vacation credits.

17.04 - BEREAVEMENT DURING VACATION

Where an employee's scheduled vacation is interrupted due to a bereavement, the employee shall be entitled to bereavement leave in accordance with Article 12.04.

The portion of the employee's vacation which is deemed to be bereavement leave under the above provisions will not be counted against the employee's vacation credits.


ARTICLE 18 HEALTH & WELFARE

18.01 INSURED BENEFITS

(The following clause is applicable to full time employees only)

The following provision will appear in all collective agreements replacing any provision related to insured benefits that existed in the hospital’s expiring Collective Agreement, (subject to inserting in the following language any percentage contribution by the Hospital which is greater than that contained in the following provision):

The Hospital agrees, during the term of the Collective Agreement, to contribute towards the premium coverage of participating eligible employees in the active employ of the Hospital under the insurance plans set out below subject to their respective terms and conditions including any enrolment requirements:

(a) The Hospital agrees to pay 100% of the billed premium towards coverage of eligible employees in the active employ of the Hospital under the Blue Cross Semi-Private Plan in effect as of September 28, 1993 or comparable coverage with another carrier.

(b) The Hospital agrees to contribute 75% of the billed premium towards coverage of eligible employees in the active employ of the Hospital under the existing Blue Cross Extended Health Care Benefits Plan in effect as of September 28, 1993 (as amended below) or comparable coverage with another carrier providing for $22.50 (single) and $35.00 (family) deductible, providing the balance of monthly premiums is paid by the employee through payroll deductions.

Reimbursement for prescribed drugs covered by the Plan will be based on the cost of the lowest priced therapeutically equivalent generic version of the drug, unless there is a documented adverse reaction to the generic drug.

Subject to superior conditions services of a chiropractor will be covered up to an annual maximum of $300; and, subject to superior conditions, services of a licensed or registered physiotherapist will be covered up to an annual maximum of $300.

Effective September 29, 2011, the annual maximums for chiropractor and licensed or registered physiotherapist will be increased to $350.

Vision care maximum $200.00 every 24 months in addition to eye examinations biennially, and hearing aide acquisition every 36 months.

Effective September 29, 2010 the vision care maximum will be increased to $250.00 every 24 months.

Effective September 29, 2011 the vision care maximum will be increased to $300.00 every 24 months. Vision care coverage can be used for laser eye surgery.

(c) The Hospital agrees to contribute 100% of the billed premium towards coverage of eligible employees in the active employ of the Hospital under HOOGLIP in effect as of September 28, 1993 or such other group life insurance plan currently in effect providing the balance of the monthly premium is paid by the employee through payroll deductions.

(d) The Hospital agrees to contribute 75% of the billed premiums towards coverage of eligible employees in the active employ of the Hospital under the Blue Cross #9 Dental Plan in effect as of September 28, 1993 or comparable coverage with another carrier.

Dental recall, including preventative services, every 9 months.

The Hospital also agrees to contribute 75% of the billed premiums towards coverage of Blue Cross rider #2 (or equivalent) [complete and partial dentures] at 50/50 co-insurance to $1000 annual maximum and Blue Cross rider #4 (or equivalent) [crowns, bridgework, and repairs to same] at 50/50 co-insurance to $1000 annual maximum providing the balance of the monthly premiums are paid by the employee through payroll deduction.

The dental plan fee schedule for services for the dental plan benefits provided above shall be based on the current ODA fee schedule as it may be updated from time to time.

(e) The Hospital will provide equivalent coverage to all employees who retire early and have not yet reached age 65 and who are in receipt of the Hospital's pension plan benefits on the same basis as is provided to active employees for semi private, extended health care and dental benefits. The Hospital will contribute the same portion towards the billed premiums of these benefits plans as is currently contributed by the Hospital to the billed premiums of active employees.

(f) A copy of all current master policies of the benefits referred to in this Article shall be provided to the Union.

18.02 CHANGE OF CARRIER
(The following clause is applicable to full time employees only)

It is understood that the Hospital may at any time substitute another carrier for any plan (other than OHIP) provided the benefits conferred thereby are not in total decreased. The Hospital shall notify the Union sixty (60) days in advance of making such a substitution to explain the proposed change and to ascertain the views of the employees. Upon a request by the Union, the Hospital shall provide to the Union, full specifications of the benefit programs contracted for and in effect for employees covered herein.

18.03 PENSION
(The following clause is applicable to full time employees only)

All present employees enrolled in the Hospital's pension plan shall maintain their enrolment in the plan subject to its terms and conditions. New employees and employees not yet eligible for membership in the plan shall, as a condition of employment, enroll in the plan when eligible in accordance with its terms and conditions.

18.04 BENEFITS FOR PART-TIME EMPLOYEES
(The following clause is applicable to part-time employees only)

A part-time employee shall receive in lieu of all fringe benefits (being those benefits to an employee, paid in whole or part by the Hospital, as part of direct compensation or otherwise, including holiday pay, save and except salary, vacation pay, standby pay, call back pay, reporting pay, responsibility allowance, jury and witness duty, bereavement pay, and maternity supplemental unemployment benefits) an amount equal to 14% of his/her regular straight time hourly rate for all straight time hours paid.

18.05 – UNION EDUCATION

If the local union indicates to the Hospital that its members have approved a special assessment for union education in accordance with the CUPE constitution and local union by laws, the Hospital agrees to deduct this assessment.

Such assessment will be paid on a quarterly basis into a trust fund established and administered by OCHU/CUPE for this purpose.

ARTICLE 19 HEALTH & SAFETY

19.01 PROTECTIVE FOOTWEAR

Effective January 1, 2002, and on that date for each subsequent calendar year, the Hospital will provide $80 per calendar year to each full time and $45 per calendar year to each regular part-time employee who is required by the Hospital to wear safety footwear during the course of his duties. The employees who will be required to wear safety footwear will be negotiated locally and set out in the Local Provisions Appendix.

Note: The existing central language designating the classifications of employees which are deemed to require appropriate safety footwear shall be transferred to the local appendix.

19.02 – INFLUENZA VACCINATION

The parties agree that influenza vaccinations may be beneficial for patients and employees. Upon a recommendation pertaining to a facility or a specifically designated area(s) thereof from the Medical Officer of Health or in compliance with applicable provincial legislation, the following rules will apply:

(a) Hospitals recognize that employees have the right to refuse any recommended or required vaccination.

(b) If an employee refuses to take the recommended or required vaccine required under this provision, she or he will be reassigned during the outbreak period, unless reassignment is not possible, in which case he or she will be placed on unpaid leave. If an employee is placed on unpaid leave, she or he can use banked lieu time or vacation credits in order to keep her or his pay whole. It is further agreed that any such reassignment will not adversely impact the scheduled hours of other employees.

(c) If an employee refuses to take the recommended or required vaccine because it is medically contra-indicated, and where a medical certificate is provided to this effect, she or he will be reassigned during the outbreak period, unless reassignment is not possible, in which case the employee will be placed on paid leave. It is further agreed that any such reassignment will not adversely impact the scheduled hours of other employees.

(d) If an employee gets sick as a result of the vaccination, and applies for WSIB, the Hospital will not oppose the claim.

(e) If the full cost of such medication is not covered by some other source, the Hospital will pay the full or incremental cost for the vaccine and will endeavour to offer vaccinations during an employee’s working hours. In addition, employees will be provided with information, including risks and side effects, regarding the vaccine.

(f) This article shall be interpreted in a manner consistent with the Ontario Human Rights Code.

ARTICLE 20 COMPENSATION

20.01 (A) - JOB CLASSIFICATION

When a new classification (which is covered by the terms of this collective agreement) is established by the Hospital, the Hospital shall determine the rate of pay for such new classification and notify the local Union of the same. If the local Union challenges the rate, it shall have the right to request a meeting with the Hospital to endeavour to negotiate a mutually satisfactory rate. Such request

will be made within ten (10) days after the receipt of notice from the Hospital of such new occupational classification and rate. Any change mutually agreed to resulting from such meeting shall be retroactive to the date that notice of the new rate was given by the Hospital. If the parties are unable to agree, the dispute concerning the new rate may be submitted to arbitration as provided in the Agreement within fifteen (15) days of such meeting. The decision of the Board of Arbitration (or Arbitrator as the case may be) shall be based on the relationship established by comparison with the rates for other classifications in the bargaining unit having regard to the requirements of such classification.

When the Hospital makes a substantial change in the job content of an existing classification which in reality causes such classification to become a new classification, the Hospital agrees to meet with the Union if requested to permit the Union to make representation with respect to the appropriate rate of pay.

If the matter is not resolved following the meeting with the Union the matter may be referred to arbitration as provided in the agreement within fifteen (15) days of such meeting. The decision of the Board of Arbitration (or Arbitrator as the case may be) shall be based on the relationship established by comparison with the rates for other classifications in the bargaining unit having regard to the requirements of such classifications.

The parties further agree that any change mutually agreed to or awarded as a result of arbitration shall be retroactive only to the date that the Union raised the issue with the Hospital.

Notwithstanding the foregoing, if as a result of compensable illness or injury covered by WSIB. an employee is unable to carry out the regular functions of her position, the Hospital may, subject to its operational requirements, establish a special classification and salary in an endeavour to provide the employee with an opportunity of continued employment. This provision shall not be construed as a guarantee that such special classification(s) will be made available or continued.

20.01(B) - JOB DESCRIPTIONS

A copy of the current job description for a bargaining unit position shall be made available to the Union upon request. When a new classification which is covered by terms of this collective agreement is created, a copy of the job description shall be forwarded to the Union at the time that the Hospital notifies the local Union of the rate of pay pursuant to article 20.01(a) above.

20.02 - ASSIGNMENT OF DUTIES FROM ANOTHER CLASSIFICATION

Where the Hospital revises the job content of an existing classification in such a manner that duties of another classification are assigned to it, the following shall apply:

(a) An employee who occupies a position which is revised in accordance with this article, and who is physically incapable of performing the revised position, will not be required to perform those additional duties which exceed the employee's physical capabilities provided the employee's physician provides documentation to the Hospital of such limitation.

(b) In the event an employee presently occupying a position which is revised in accordance with this article requires additional training to perform duties of the revised position the employee shall be entitled to a period of training, with due consideration being given to the employee's age and previous educational background, during which they may perfect or
acquire the skills necessitated by the new method of operation. The employer will assume the cost of tuition and travel. There shall be no reduction in wage or salary rates during the training period of any such employee. Training shall be given during the hours of work whenever possible and may extend for up to six months.

20.03 - PROMOTION TO A HIGHER CLASSIFICATION

An employee who is promoted to a higher rated classification within the bargaining unit will be placed in the range of the higher rated classification so that he shall receive no less an increase in wage rate than the equivalent of one step in the wage rate of his previous classification (provided that he does not exceed the wage rate of the classification to which he has been promoted).

20.04 WAGES AND CLASSIFICATION PREMIUMS

Provisions under these headings shall remain unchanged and are repeated as 20.04, except to the extent that the Wage Schedule referred to in the hospital's expiring collective agreement shall be adjusted and retroactivity shall be paid in accordance with the Implementation Agreement signed.

20.05 PROGRESSION ON THE WAGE GRID
(The following clause is applicable to part-time employees only)

Effective October 10, 1986 part-time employees, including casual employees, shall accumulate service for the purpose of progression on the wage grid, on the basis of one year for each 1725 hours worked.

Notwithstanding the above, employees hired prior to October 10, 1986 will be credited with the service they held for the purpose of progression on the wage grid under the Agreement expiring September 28, 1985 and will thereafter accumulate service in accordance with this Article.

ARTICLE 21 FISCAL ADVISORY COMMITTEE

(a) The Union's representative(s) will be included in the consultation and planning process from the early phases of the budget planning process, through representation on the Fiscal Advisory Committee, to its final stages of completion, to assist the Hospital in minimizing layoffs or job loss, and in developing labour adjustment strategies where necessary.

(b) Where the Hospital experiences unforeseen circumstances such that will necessitate changes to its budgetary plans which have been approved by the Ministry of Health, or the Local Health Integration Network, the Hospital agrees that revisions to the budget will be carried out in consultation with the Union.

(c) In furtherance of the foregoing, the Hospital agrees to provide to the Union in a timely way any financial and staffing information pertinent to its budget, or to any other re-structuring plan that would affect the Union's members.

(d) It is understood that employee time spent at meetings with the employer in pursuance of the above shall be deemed to be work time for which the employee shall be paid by the Hospital at his or her regular or premium rate as may be applicable.

ARTICLE 22 APPRENTICESHIP COMMITTEE

The central parties agree that within sixty (60) days of the commencement of this agreement, a joint local committee consisting of up to three representatives each will be formed to discuss the feasibility of establishing an apprenticeship

Program (s). If such a program is deemed feasible, the local parties will determine the terms and conditions of such program(s).
The joint local committee will seek the availability of any federal or provincial funds to cover the costs of such programs.

ARTICLE 23 DURATION

23.01 - TERM

This agreement shall be binding and continue in effect and shall continue from year to year unless either party gives written notice to the other party of its desire to bargain for amendments within ninety (90) days prior to the termination date of September 28, 2013. Upon receipt of such notice by one party or the other, both parties will meet thereafter for the purpose of bargaining.

23.02 - CENTRAL BARGAINING

Notwithstanding the foregoing provisions, in the event the parties to this Agreement agree to negotiate for its renewal through the process of central bargaining, either party to this Agreement may give notice to the other party of its desire to bargain for amendments on local matters proposed for incorporation in the renewal of this Agreement and negotiations on local matters shall take place during the period from 120 to 60 days prior to the termination date of this Agreement. Negotiations on central matters shall take place during the period commencing forty-five days prior to the termination date of this Agreement.

It is understood and agreed that "local matters" means, those matters which have been determined by mutual agreement between the central negotiating committees respectively representing each of the parties to this Agreement as being subjects for local bargaining directly between the parties to this Agreement. It is also agreed that local bargaining shall be subject to such procedures that may be determined by mutual agreements between the central negotiating committees referred to above. For such purposes, it is further understood that the central negotiating committees will meet during the sixth month prior to the month of termination of this Agreement to convey the intentions of their principals as to possible participation in central negotiations, if any, and the conditions for such central bargaining.







FULL TIME COLLECTIVE AGREEMENT

Expires: September 28, 2013
Click here to download

PART TIME COLLECTIVE AGREEMENT

Expires: September 28, 2013
Click here to download

MEMORANDUM OF CONDITIONS FOR JOINT BARGAINING

BETWEEN:

THE PARTICIPATING HOSPITALS
Listed in Appendix “A”
(hereinafter called the “Hospitals”)

AND

THE CANADIAN UNION OF PUBLIC EMPLOYEES
On its own behalf and on behalf of each of its Local Unions listed in Appendix “A”
(hereinafter called the “Union”)


The Union and the Hospitals have established and authorized their respective Central Negotiating Committees as set forth in Appendix “B”, who may be accompanied by their Counsel and others from time to time, for the purpose of bargaining on those issues identified by the parties hereto as central issues and coordinating the resolution of local issues to the extent provided herein.

It is the desire and intent of the Union and the Hospital to provide a method of orderly collective bargaining and to negotiate in good faith through their respective Central Negotiating Committees under the provisions of the applicable legislation with a view to renewing the present Collective Agreement for each bargaining unit in each of the Hospitals covered hereby for which the Union has bargaining rights subject to the following conditions:

1. (a) The issues for central bargaining shall be determined by the Central Negotiating Committees and may include but shall not go beyond those set out in Appendix “C” attached hereto. It is understood that the identification of any issue as a “central” issue shall be without prejudice to either party as to the merits or negotiability of such issue. Each Central Negotiating Committee shall submit to the other its proposals on central issues no later than March 2, 2009. A notice to bargain on behalf of all of the participating Local Unions shall be served by the Union’s Central Negotiating Committee, in respect of Central Issues on March 2nd, 2009 and in respect of Local issues on September 28, 2009. The parties agree to meet in central negotiations on the following dates: March 2 to March 10, 2009.


(b) In order to ensure the availability of a conciliation officer to assist the parties during the bargaining of central issues, either party may upon the signing of this Memorandum request the Ministry of Labour to appoint a conciliation officer to meet with the parties between March 2 and March 10, 2009.

(c) Apart from the negotiations conducted between the two Central Negotiating Committees, there shall be no bargaining by the Local Unions with any Participating Hospital or Hospitals with respect to any central issue and any agreement on any central issue arising from any such unauthorized bargaining shall be null and void.

2. (a) All issues other than those identified by the Central Negotiating Committees as central issues will be considered local issues between each Local Union and each Hospital. It is understood that the identification of any issue as a “local” issue shall be without prejudice to either party as to the merits or negotiability of such issue. Each Local Union and each Hospital shall submit to the other, and to its respective Central Negotiating Committee, its proposals, if any, on local issues no later than January 31, 2010. The Central Negotiating Committees shall review these proposals on local issues within thirty (30) days of receiving them in order to ensure that all such proposals are properly local in nature. Bargaining on local issues between the respective Hospitals and Local Unions shall commence no earlier than March 3, 2010 and shall not continue beyond June 30, 2010.

(b) In the event a Hospital and Local Union are unable to achieve a negotiated settlement on local issues, conciliation and mediation proceedings under the auspices of the Ontario Ministry of Labour may be utilized at the option of either party.

3. (a) The parties to this Memorandum shall appoint their nominees to the Board of Arbitration, which is responsible for the unresolved central issues, and their nominees to the Board of Arbitration, which is responsible for the unresolved local issues, no later than April 1, 2009. The nominees shall forthwith attempt to agree upon a third member to act as Chairperson of each of the respective boards. Should there be no such agreement then, the Minister of Labour shall be requested to make the appointment(s).

(b) In order to expedite the arbitration process, the parties will request the Board referred to in (a) above established in respect of central issues to reserve the first available dates prior to June 30, 2009, subject to availability of the Board of Arbitration, for the purpose of setting hearing dates and executive sessions. The Central Parties will request that the central Board of Arbitration will render its decision by August 31, 2009. Further, the parties will request the Board referred to in (a) above established in respect of local issues to reserve the first available dates following September 30, 2010 for the purpose of setting hearing dates and executive sessions.

4. (a) In the event any central issues are submitted to arbitration, the Central Negotiating Committees shall each appoint representatives to an Implementation Committee which will attempt to conclude an Implementation Agreement. If the Committee cannot agree on an Implementation Agreement within thirty days of the issuance of the award, either Central Negotiating Committee may request the Central Issues Arbitration Board to award an Implementation Agreement and shall provide a copy of its request to make written submissions to the Board, and the Board shall award an Implementation Agreement on the basis of the material available to it within this thirty day period.

(b) Any difficulties experienced by a Hospital or a Local Union in incorporating the provisions of the Implementation Agreement into their Collective Agreement shall be referred to the Implementation Committee not later than forty-five days following the date of the Implementation Agreement. The Implementation Committee shall be empowered to resolve any difficulties or problems as it may in its discretion see fit and appropriate. Any agreement reached by the Implementation Committee shall be binding on the respective Hospital and Local Union concerned.


5. Should the parties be successful in negotiating a settlement of all central issues the Hospitals will implement the central issues in accordance with the terms of settlement, subject to satisfying the procedures required under the applicable legislation, and will not delay implementation until all local issues have been resolved.

6. Any settlement agreed to by the Hospitals’ Central Negotiating Committee will be recommended to the Participating Hospitals for ratification. Ratification by at least two thirds of the Participating Hospitals employing at least two-thirds of the affected employees shall constitute ratification by all Participating Hospitals.

7. (a) Any settlement agreed to by the participating Hospital’s Central Negotiating Committee and the Union’s Central Negotiating Committee will be unanimously recommended for ratification.

(b) A vote of the members of each Local Union will take place at the respective place of employment and to be carried out in such a manner as to allow all members of the bargaining unit to vote. Any Central Settlement which is ratified by a simple majority of votes cast shall constitute ratification by all participating Local Unions. Ratification votes cast shall be counted on a province-wide basis.

8. The agreement on central issues arising out of negotiations or arbitration shall not be altered in any way by either party at the local level and shall be implemented and deemed to be in affect notwithstanding any failure to resolve local issues, subject to satisfying the procedures required under the applicable legislation.

9. Any settlement of local issues will be subject to ratification at the local level.

10. The renewal Collective Agreement(s) at each participating Hospital will consist of the appropriate standard central provisions format resulting from the current round of central bargaining and appropriate appendices of local and other issues.

11. It is understood that, except as otherwise referred to in Appendix “A”, the bargaining unit and Collective Agreement of a Hospital covered hereby shall be the existing bargaining unit and Collective Agreement.

12. The Union, while observing its obligation under the legislation to members employed by other public Hospitals will attempt to conduct negotiations with public Hospitals not participating in this joint bargaining mechanism so as not to adversely affect the purpose of this joint bargaining and furthermore neither of the parties to this agreement will disclose at arbitration any reference to a settlement achieved by the Union with a non participating Hospital.

Dated at Toronto, Ontario this 2nd day of March, 2009.

ON BEHALF OF THE CANADIAN UNION OF PUBLIC EMPLOYEES

ON BEHALF OF THE
PARTICIPATING HOSPITALS


APPENDIX “A”

PARTICIPATING HOSPITALS - CUPE 2009

HOSPITALS

Alexandria, Glengarry Memorial Hospital
Alexandria, Glengarry Memorial Hospital
Almonte General Hospital
Arnprior & District Memorial Hospital
Blind River, Blind River District Health Centre
Brampton, William Osler Health Centre
Brockville General Hospital
Burlington, Joseph Brant Memorial Hospital
Campbellford Memorial Hospital
Carleton Place & District Memorial Hospital
Chapleau, Services De Sante De Chapleau
Cobourg, Northumberland Health Care Centre
Cornwall Community Hospital
Espanola General Hospital
Riverside Health Care Facilities
-Emo
Fort Frances
Rainy River
Georgetown, Halton Healthcare Services
Geraldton District Hospital
Guelph General Hospital
Guelph, St. Joseph’s Health Centre
Haliburton Highlands Health Services – Hyland Crest
Hamilton, St. Joseph's Health Care
Hawkesbury & District General Hospital
Hearst, Notre Dame Hospital
Hornepayne Community Hospital
Huron-Perth Healthcare Alliance
- Clinton Public Hospital
- St. Mary’s Memorial Hospital
- Seaforth Community Hospital
- Stratford General Hospital
Kenora, Lake of the Woods District Hospital
Kingston General Hospital
Lindsay, Ross Memorial Hospital
Little Current, Manitoulin Health Centre
Markham Stouffville Hospital (Markham and Uxbridge)
Mattawa General Hospital
Midland and Penetanguishene, North Simcoe Hospital Alliance
Mississauga, Credit Valley Hospital
Mississauga, Trillium Health Centre
North Bay General Hospital
Oshawa, Lakeridge Health Corporation
Ottawa, Queensway-Carleton Hospital
Ottawa, Royal Ottawa Health Care Group
Pembroke Regional Hospital
Peterborough Regional Health Centre
Red Lake Margaret Cochenour Memorial Hospital
Renfrew Victoria Hospital
Rouge Valley Health System (Scarborough and Ajax)
Smiths Falls, Perth & Smiths Falls District Hospital
Sturgeon Falls, West Nipissing General Hospital
Sudbury Regional Hospital
Toronto, Hospital for Sick Children
Toronto, Providence Healthcare
Toronto, The Scarborough Hospital
Toronto Rehabilitation Institute
Toronto, St. Joseph’s Health Centre
Toronto, Salvation Army Toronto Grace Hospital
Toronto, St. John's Rehabilitation Hospital
Winchester District Memorial Hospital
Wingham & District Hospital

APPENDIX "B"

CENTRAL NEGOTIATING COMMITTEES

HOSPITALS' NEGOTIATING TEAM - CUPE


CHAIRPERSON:

Wayne Simpson Vice-President, Human Resources
The Scarborough Hospital, Toronto

SPOKESPERSON:

W. Matthew Sutcliffe Senior Employee Relations Consultant
Ontario Hospital Association

MEMBERS:

Kenneth Gazdic Director, Materials Management
Sudbury Regional Hospital

Aileen Edwards Director, Human Resources
Providence Healthcare, Toronto

Vinnie Berman Director, Human Resources Operations
Toronto Grace Health Centre, Toronto

Rhonda Lewis Director, People Practice
Trillium Health Centre

Varujan Gharakanian Senior Manager, Human Resources
St. Joseph’s Healthcare, Hamilton

Jeanette Clarke-Boutilier Manager, Medicine/Telemetry
Rouge Valley Health System

OHA STAFF:

Sam Mandelbaum Director
Hospital Employee Relations Services

W. Matthew Sutcliffe Senior Employee Relations Consultant
Hospital Employee Relations Services

Caroline Van Kessel Employee Relations Consultant
Hospital Employee Relations Services

Arlene Papaioannou Employee Relations Consultant
Hospital Employee Relations Services

David McCoy Assistant Consultant
Hospital Employee Relations Services


UNION'S NEGOTIATING COMMITTEE - CUPE

MEMBERSHIP LIST

Michael Hurley
Council President

Helen Fetterly
Council Secretary/Treasurer


Area Vice-Presidents:

Ann Huffmon
(Guelph St. Joseph’s Health Centre)

Brenda Wells
(Hamilton Health Sciences)

Joe Reddy
(Markham Stouffville Hospital)

Diane Crough
(Peterborough Regional Health Centre)

Louis Rodrigues
(Kingston General Hospital)

Sharon Richer
(Sudbury Regional Hospital)

Judy Bain
(Lake-of-the-Woods District Hospital, Kenora)

Marc Lafrance
(Ottawa Hopital Montfort)

CUPE Health Care Coordinator:
Gwen Hewitt

Senior Research Officers:
Margaret Evans
Doug Allan

APPENDIX “C”

ISSUES APPROPRIATE FOR CENTRAL BARGAINING

1. Purpose Preamble
Feminine/Masculine Pronouns

2. Definitions Temporary Employees
Part-Time Commitment
Regular Part-Time Employee
Casual Employee

3. Relationship No Discrimination

4. Strike and Lockouts

5. Union Security T4 Slips
Notifications to Union
Employee Interview
No Other Agreements

6. Union Representation and Committees Union Activity on Premises
Access to Premises
Labour Management Committee
Local Bargaining Committee
(number and structure are local issues)
Central Bargaining Committee
Pay for Grievance Committee or Stewards
(number and structure are local issues)

7. Grievance and Arbitration Procedure

8. Discharge, Suspension and Discipline Access to Personal File
Employee’s Record
Right to have Steward present
Warnings

9. Seniority Probationary period
Definition of Seniority
Loss of Seniority
Effect of Absence
Job Posting
Transfer and Seniority Outside the Bargaining Unit
Transfer of Seniority and Service
Notice of Layoff
Layoff and Recall
Benefits on Layoff
Technological Change

10. Job Security Contracting out
Work of the Bargaining Unit
Volunteers

11. Leaves of Absence Personal Leave
Union Business
(except number of employees and number of days)
Number of days notice
Full-Time Position with the Union or
Full-time Public Office
Bereavement Leave
Jury and Witness Duty
Pregnancy Leave
Parental Leave
Education Leave
Any Other Leave of Absence Provision

12. Sick Leave, Injury and Disability HOODIP
Sick Leave Entitlement, including penalty clauses
Accumulation
Cashout
Injury Pay
Payroll Deduction for Union-Sponsored
LTD Plan
(Modified Work Committees and Return to Work arrangements are local)

13. Hours of Work Daily and Weekly Hours of Work
(excluding Scheduling) Rest Periods
Additional Rest Periods

14. Premium Payment Definition of Regular Straight Time Rate of Pay
Definition of Overtime
Overtime Premium and No Pyramiding
Time Off in Lieu of Overtime
Reporting Pay
Call Back
Standby
Temporary Transfer
Shift and Weekend Premium
Transfer to Lower Paying Classification

15. Holidays Number of Holidays
Definition of Holiday Pay and Qualifiers
Payment for Working on a Holiday
Payment for Working Overtime on a Holiday

16. Vacation Full and Part-Time Vacation Entitlement
Qualifiers and Calculation of Payment
Work During Vacation

17. Health & Welfare Illness During Vacation
Insured Benefits
Change of Carrier
Pension
Benefits for Part-Time Employees

18. Health & Safety Protective Footwear

19. Compensation Job Classification
Promotion to a Higher Classification
Progression on the Wage Grid (Part-Time) General Wage Increases
Retroactivity
(All monetary items for Registered Technologists are local)

20. Previously Agreed Standard Clauses

21. Superior Benefits

22. Term Length of Agreement
Joint Technical Committee
(Re-opener Dates, Local/Central Determination, Central Participation)

23. Part-Time Employees Definition, and Application of Agreement to Part-time Employees if in Bargaining Unit, except that the definition cannot affect the Scope Provisions of Collective Agreement

24. Professional Responsibility

25. Workload

Enter the name for this tabbed section: Bill 122

Presentation by the Ontario Council of Hospital Unions /CUPE to the Standing Committee on Social Policy

Re: Bill 122
Prepared with the assistance of
Sack Goldblatt Mitchell LLP
November 2010


We would like to thank the Standing Committee for allowing us to present our views on Bill 122 – The Broader Public Sector Accountability Act, 2010.

The Ontario Council of Hospital Unions/CUPE (“OCHU”) represents 26,000 nursing, service, and office workers employed in 120 bargaining units across Ontario. While a large majority of OCHU members provide hospital services, some OCHU members work in long term care facilities or in Emergency Medical Services, usually (but not always) under the auspices of a local hospital board.

OCHU is committed to a publically funded and publically accountable health care system. OCHU is also committed to ensuring that employees in the health care sector are protected by fair and reasonable terms and conditions of employment, and that, consistent with the government’s commitment to respect for collective agreements, the process of collective bargaining in the health care sector is not undermined.

In general, OCHU supports greater transparency and accountability in the provision of public health services, including Bill 122’s more stringent regulations governing the use of consultants and reporting expenses. However, it is our view that these measures must be expanded and strengthened. We are concerned that the proposed provisions respecting lobbying will create an unequal playing field, and erode our collective commitment to publicly financed and delivered health care services. Private, for-profit participants in the health care sector will be free to lobby government for public funds in order to privatize the system, while public institutions will be constrained from advocating for an effective public system.

As set out below, OCHU is also very concerned about the wide powers given to government to dictate the terms upon which goods and services will be procured by public institutions. In this connection, we are concerned that, without clear criteria, procurement directives may lead to the privatization of health services and the erosion of the quality of the health care system.

OCHU is particularly concerned about the possibility that Bill 122’s proposed provisions relating to procurement standards could be interpreted – unintentionally we assume – to override collective agreement job security protections, and will not be subject to sufficient public consultation and discussion. Further, the procurement and enforcement provisions of the Bill lack sufficient clarity and could be interpreted as interfering with collective agreement protections. Therefore, OCHU requests that the Bill be amended to make clear that it is not intended to interfere with freely negotiated collective agreements.


Procurement Standards (Bill 122: Part V, ss. 12 and 13)

Section 12 of Bill 122 provides that the Management Board of Cabinet may issue directives governing the procurement of goods and services by designated public sector organizations. Such directives may incorporate by reference a Government of Ontario policy or directive, in whole or in part, and as amended from time to time. In addition, section 13 provides that the Management Board of Cabinet may make guidelines with respect to the procurement of goods and services by publicly funded organizations.

OCHU is troubled that Bill 122 does not define what “procurement” means and, therefore, gives no indication of the intended scope of ss. 12 and 13. Similarly, Bill 122 does not contain any criteria, rules or limitations with respect to the content of the directives that the Management Board of Cabinet may issue.

OCHU is concerned that the Bill’s lack of clarity with respect to the extent to which a government may regulate procurement could, for example, be interpreted as allowing the government to impose a system of competitive bidding on hospitals, community care access centres (“CCACs”) and local health integration networks (“LHINs”) that requires contracts to be let to the lowest bidder, irrespective of the effect of such action on health care system quality and accessibility, the well-being of patients and the terms and conditions of employment of health care workers.

The results of a system of this type of competitive bidding system in the home care sector, with which OHCU has significant experience, have been extremely destructive. The process of competitive bidding has led to an increase in the number of for-profit service providers in that sector and, as contracts come up for renewal, workers protected by collective agreements have been laid off and replaced by non-union personnel. In Cornwall alone, home care staff lost their jobs on at least three separate occasions after competitive bidding was introduced. OCHU is extremely concerned that Bill 122 may allow the government to institute this type of system of competitive bidding throughout the health care sector simply by issuing directives, and may do so without having regard to the consequences of increased privatization for both workers and patients.

The open-endedness in the Bill’s procurement provisions also raises a concern that directives issued under Part V may be used to override longstanding collective agreement protections, for example, with respect to contracting out. In this regard, OCHU has attempted to safeguard the right of its members to bargain collectively and their terms and conditions of employment by negotiating contracting out protections that require contractors to honour the terms and conditions of the collective agreement. These contracting out protections are of fundamental importance to any collective agreement.

OCHU’s concerns relating to collective agreement protections stemming from the lack of clarity in the Bill’s procurement provisions are heightened by the enforcement provisions in Part VII of the Bill. Section 21 appears to provide that an “agreement” that conflicts with a requirement under the Bill is “not valid or enforceable by any party to the agreement”.

While we would not have thought it was the government’s intent to capture collective agreements by this section, there is a risk, given the ambiguity of the language, that section 21 could invalidate collective agreement provisions entered into after the provisions of Part V come into effect if they conflict with a directive issued under the statute.

These concerns are compounded by sections 22 and 23 of the Bill, which appear to insulate organizations from any form of legal action where they are acting in furtherance of directives issued under the statute. Section 22 provides that no cause of action can arise against the Crown, or any of its ministers, agents, appointees and employees, or an organization subject to the statute, as a direct or indirect result of the enactment or repeal of any provision of the statute, the making or revocation of any regulation, directive or guideline, or anything done or not done in accordance with the statute. These restrictions apply not only to an action, but also to any “other proceeding” in which any kind of remedy or relief is claimed.

Section 23 stipulates that “despite any other Act or law, no person is entitled to any compensation for any loss or damages … arising from the enactment or application of this Act or anything done in accordance with this Act, the regulations or directives…”.
OCHU is concerned that any legal action, including grievances to enforce a collective agreement, might be caught by these provisions, unless the provisions are clarified. For all these reasons, OCHU requests that Bill 122 be amended to make clear and certain the government’s intention that directives issued by Management Board will not and cannot interfere with or override collective agreements.

OCHU’s concerns respecting collective bargaining also serve to highlight important questions concerning the public interest that may be raised by procurement directives. Various institutions in the health care sector may wish to provide preferences in their procurement policies to local producers or employers who pay fair wages or to non-profit entities. The Bill appears to allow the government to make decisions with respect to which criteria institutions can and cannot include in their procurement policies through an entirely secretive and unregulated process by government, in which none of the public interest concerns can be adequately debated.

In OCHU’s view, there must be greater transparency in the procurement process, and the measures to achieve that transparency should be contained in the statute itself and not left solely to directives and regulations. Just as Bill 122 imposes reporting requirements in respect to consultants and requirements to make information relating to expenses public, all contracts entered into using public funds should be open to the public to examine and inspect.

It is OCHU’s position that these debates should occur before, and not after, the provisions of this Bill are enacted, and it is concerned that the haste with which the Bill is proceeding through the legislative process will not allow this thorough public debate to occur.


Lobbyists and Consultants (Bill 122: Part II, ss. 4-7)

As noted above, OHCU supports the government’s goal of greater transparency and accountability with respect to the use of public funds in the health care system. However, in respect of lobbying it is OCHU’s view that Bill 122 draws an illogical and unfair distinction between not-for-profit and for-profit organizations, even though both types of bodies may receive significant government funding. The effect of limiting public institutions in their ability to lobby the government, without placing similar constraints on lobbyists for private, for-profit interests, cannot help but skew the governmental decision-making process and bias it in favour of the private provision of services.

In this regard, section 4 of the Bill provides that the rules regarding lobbyists and consultants applies to, among other bodies, every “designated broader public sector organization”. The definition of “designated broader public sector organization” includes “every publically funded organization that received public funds of 10 million dollars or more in the previous fiscal year…”.

However, the Bill’s definition of “publically funded organization” specifically excludes organizations that undertake their activities “for the purpose of profit to … shareholders” (unless regulations are otherwise enacted). Consequently, even where an organization receives virtually all of its funding from the government, if it undertakes activities for the purpose of profit to shareholders, it is excluded from the definition of a publically funded organization and thus from the definition of a “designated broader public sector organization”. It would not, therefore, be subject to the new rules governing lobbyists and consultants.

As a result, a publically funded organization that received at least 10 million dollars from the government in its previous fiscal year would be subject to Part II of the statute, but a for-profit enterprise that received the same amount of funding from the government would not have to comply with Part II. In addition, long term care homes, which include for-profit nursing homes which receive enormous amounts of public funds, are also specifically excluded from the definition of “publically funded organization” and are therefore not subject to the rules governing lobbyists. There is no discernable or acceptable public policy rationale for this unequal and biased treatment.

Further, public hospitals and LHINs are completely prohibited from hiring lobbyists whereas private operators who wish to privatize parts of a public hospital’s operation remain free to lobby government. This cannot help but have an adverse long-term effect on the well-being of public, non-profit institutions.

In OCHU’s view, it makes no sense to exclude for-profit entities from the requirements of Bill 122. This will create an incongruous situation in which for-profit entities will be able to use any of their funds, including public funds received from the government, to hire lobbyists, while public, not-for-profit entities will be constrained by the provisions of Bill 122.
In OCHU’s view, therefore, Bill 122 should be amended to provide that for-profit organizations that operate in the health care sector must also comply with the statute’s provisions.

With respect to the use of consultants, OCHU observes that Bill 122 requires only hospitals and LHINs to report on their use of consultants. In the absence of regulations setting out similar requirements, other broader public sector organizations or private for-profit organizations that receive significant government funding do not have to report on their use of consultants. The reasons for this distinction are unclear.

Further, the Bill would require that only hospitals and LHINs prepare reports. The content of the reports is left to Ministerial directive. There is currently no provision, as there is with expense claim information, that the reports will be made available to the public. Further, it is unclear why the reporting requirements are limited to contracts engaging consultants.

There are many significant contracts which are entered into for goods and services which may be subject to abuse and in respect of which the public is entitled to have full information. Broader public sector organizations spend much more funding on contracting out work to other sorts of providers - work that would otherwise be done by unionized employees of the hospital; work involving vital parts of the work of the hospital such as infection control and food. There is unfortunately no requirement to report on these sorts of contracts.

Yet this is where the major portion of contracting out goes on, and likely where the major savings could be achieved. Indeed, we find great difficulty getting any information from hospitals about such contracts.

Tomorrow, for example, in Kingston the hospital board will vote on contracting out the food services to a very large transnational corporation. This will mean trucking in food from Toronto. The hospital has not met our requests for information and we fully expect that once contracted out, information about the work will become shielded by a veil of commercial confidentiality.

We believe the required reports on consultant contracts should be expanded to reports on all contracts for goods and services. As we noted in our comments related to procurement, the public should have full access to the details of all contracts entered into by public institutions using public money.

In OCHU’s view, Bill 122 leaves too much to directive and regulation, and fails to impose the very transparency and public accountability which is the legislation’s underlying rationale.

Finally, OCHU is particularly concerned that long term care homes, which may receive significant public funding, are not required to report on their use of consultants and are not restricted in any way in respect to their use of consultants.

In OCHU’s view, Bill 122 should be amended to provide that all organizations that receive significant public funds, whether public or private, should be subject to the same rules.

Public Reporting of Expense Claim Information; Expense Claims: Allowable Expenses (Bill 122: Parts III and IV, ss. 8-11)

OCHU supports Bill 122’s provisions requiring the public reporting of expense claim information and the government’s intention to develop rules relating to allowable expenses.

However, OCHU does not agree that these requirements should be restricted to hospitals and LHINs. All organizations, including private, for-profit organizations such private long term care homes that receive significant government funding, should be subject to the same requirements.

Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act (Bill 122, Party VIII, s. 24)

OCHU supports Bill 122’s amendments to the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act (FIPPA) to bring hospitals within the scope of FIPPA.

However, as with the provisions governing expenses, OCHU sees no reason why other broader public sector organizations that receive significant government funding, but are not currently covered by privacy legislation, should not also be subject to FIPPA, including other actors in the health care system such as long term care homes.

In conclusion, it is important to observe that the Government’s unwillingness or inability to place constraints on the private sector in respect to matters relating to reporting of expenses, access to information, or use of consultants, makes a compelling case for public services to continue to be provided by public institutions.

Unlike hospitals, private corporations that receive public funding will not be required to report on their use of consultants, nor their executive expenses. Nor will they be subject to freedom of information requests. This is just one more reminder of why public delivery of publicly funded services is much more appropriate. The requirements of transparency, oversight and accountability which this Bill seeks to further can only be effectively met through the provision of these fundamentally important services through public organizations.


Ontario Council of Hospital Unions/CUPE
205 Richmond Street West
Suite 502
Toronto, Ontario
M5V 1V3

Sack Goldblatt Mitchell LLP
20 Dundas Street West
Suite 1100, P.O. Box 180
Toronto, Ontario
M5G 2G8

© 2009 OCHU Contact